- Peter and Judas were both sorry; what made the difference was where the sorrow went.
- Repentance is a turning of the whole life to God, and God’s grace moves first.
- Sorrow may begin in fear and grow into love; both are gifts, and the sacrament carries the weaker to its end.
- Sin has depths, and repentance must reach as deep as the sin: first leaving it, then losing the love of it.
- A house swept but left empty is reoccupied, so repentance must fill as well as clear, and the sin told loses its power.
- Penance is the second plank after shipwreck: the mercy of baptism, now costing tears, given through a priest who serves and does not own it.
- Satisfaction repairs and replaces, and frequent confession cuts the thread a little at a time.
- The Father runs to meet us and interrupts the speech: mercy is quicker than our confession.
Let us begin with two men on the same night. Both had sat at the Lord’s table, and both failed him within hours. Peter denied him three times beside a fire, and Judas handed him over for silver. Then both were sorry.
Matthew says that Judas repented, carried the thirty pieces back, said “I have sinned,” and went out and hanged himself. Luke says that when the cock crowed the Lord turned and looked at Peter, and Peter went out and wept bitterly.
Preachers have long noticed that the word Matthew uses for Judas, metamelētheis, is a word for regret and not the usual word for conversion, metanoia. The New Testament is not perfectly tidy in its vocabulary, so I would offer this as a teaching contrast and not as a rule of Greek, but the contrast is real.
Same sorrow, opposite direction
Paul gives us the principle in one sentence. Godly sorrow produces a repentance that leads to salvation and leaves nothing to regret, while the sorrow of the world produces death (2 Cor 7:10). So the question to put to any sorrow is where it goes. Does it go toward the Father, or does it fold back on itself?
Notice also what moved Peter. Ambrose, as Augustine reports him, observes that Peter did not weep at the first denial or the second. He wept when the Lord turned and looked at him. The tears were a response, which is why the Catechism insists that conversion is first of all the work of God’s grace, who makes our hearts return to him (CCC 1432).
We repent because we have been looked at.
Ambrose has another line that I want to keep for later: “I read of his tears, but I do not read of his explanation.” Peter offered no defence. We will meet him again at the confessional.
- Denied him three times
- The Lord looked at him
- Wept bitterly
- Turned back to Christ
- Handed him over
- Returned the silver
- “I have sinned”
- Folded in on himself
Godly sorrow leads to salvation; the sorrow of the world produces death (2 Cor 7:10).
Repentance is measured by the direction the sorrow takes, and the first mover is God, who looks at us first.
4 witnesses: 2 Corinthians 7:10, Luke 22:61–62, CCC 1432…
For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation and brings no regret, but worldly grief produces death.
St Paul distinguishes two griefs by where they lead. The lecture takes this as the test for any sorrow.
And the Lord turned and looked at Peter. And Peter remembered the word of the Lord … And he went out and wept bitterly.
St Luke alone records the Lord’s look. The tears follow the look, which is the order the lecture draws out.
Conversion is first of all a work of the grace of God who makes our hearts return to him.
The Church teaches that God moves first in every conversion. Peter’s tears answer the Lord’s look.
I read of his tears, but I do not read of his explanation.
St Ambrose sees that Peter offered tears and no defence. The Latin word is *satisfactionem*, rendered in other translations as “excuse” or “satisfaction”.
PonderWhen I am sorry for a sin, does my sorrow run toward the Father, or does it fold back on itself?
What the Church means by repentance
The Catechism’s definition is demanding. Interior repentance is a radical reorientation of the whole of life, a return to God with all our heart, an end of sin and a turning away from evil, with repugnance toward the evil actions we have committed (CCC 1431). It is a turning of the whole person, and a feeling alone does not qualify. The prophet says the same: return with all your heart, and “rend your hearts and not your garments” (Joel 2:12–13).
The Church gives the sacrament five names, and each is a window onto the same reality: conversion, penance, confession, forgiveness and reconciliation (CCC 1423 and 1424). Conversion names the turning, penance the discipline that expresses it, confession the telling of the sins, forgiveness the pardon given, and reconciliation the friendship restored.
The classical manuals compress what the penitent brings into a three-part line: contritio cordis, confessio oris, satisfactio operis, which is sorrow of the heart, confession of the mouth and satisfaction by deed. Thomas Aquinas calls these acts the quasi-matter of the sacrament, the raw material that absolution completes, and the priest’s words of absolution its form (ST III, q. 84, a. 1). The practical meaning is that God asks us to bring something real to be forgiven, and that we cannot forgive ourselves into peace.
The formula of absolution (CCC 1449) names the Father of mercies, the death and resurrection of the Son, and the Spirit sent for the forgiveness of sins, and it ends with the Church’s ministry and the words “I absolve you.” The sacrament is Trinitarian and ecclesial at once.
Psalm 51 is the prayer of the contrite. David asks God to blot out his transgressions, wash him thoroughly from his iniquity, and cleanse him from his sin (Ps 51:1–2). The Hebrew uses three words for sin (rebellion, twistedness, and missing the mark) and three verbs for what God does: to wipe out, as a record is erased; to wash, as cloth is scrubbed; and to purify, as in ritual cleansing.
Repentance is a radical turning of the whole life to God; in the sacrament we bring contrition, confession and satisfaction, and the Church gives absolution.
4 witnesses: CCC 1431, Joel 2:13, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae III q.84…
Interior repentance is a radical reorientation of our whole life, a return, a conversion to God with all our heart, an end of sin, a turning away from evil, with repugnance toward the evil actions we have committed.
The lecture follows the Church’s definition closely. Repentance is a turning of the whole person, not a feeling alone.
and rend your hearts and not your garments. Return to the Lord, your God.
The Lord speaks through the prophet of an inward turning that outward signs cannot replace.
The acts of the penitent are as the matter of this sacrament; the words of absolution are its form.
St Thomas teaches that the penitent’s acts are the quasi-matter which absolution completes. The article number should be confirmed against an edition.
God, the Father of mercies, through the death and resurrection of his Son has reconciled the world to himself and sent the Holy Spirit among us for the forgiveness of sins; through the ministry of the Church may God give you pardon and peace, and I absolve you from your sins in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
The Church’s words of absolution are Trinitarian and ecclesial, as the lecture notes.
PonderWhich of the five names of the sacrament speaks most to me, and why?
Why we are sorry: fear, hope and love
Contrition holds first place among the penitent’s acts. The Catechism, following Trent, defines it as “sorrow of the soul and detestation for the sin committed, together with the resolution not to sin again” (CCC 1451).
- When it comes from a love in which God is loved above all, it is called perfect, and it can obtain forgiveness even of mortal sin before confession, as long as it includes the firm resolution to confess as soon as possible (1452).
- When it comes from the ugliness of sin or the fear of damnation, it is called imperfect, or attrition (1453).
Trent adds that attrition, if it excludes the will to sin and includes hope of pardon, is a gift of God and a prompting of the Holy Spirit, who moves the penitent without yet dwelling in him, and that it prepares him to receive pardon in the sacrament. By itself it cannot obtain forgiveness of grave sin, but it disposes the penitent for it. This is a real comfort for people who say their sorrow is “only fear.” Fear is where many of us begin, and the Spirit uses it. The other side must also be said: perfect contrition is never a loophole around confession, because it always includes the intention to confess.
Gregory the Great gives the image. In the Dialogues (III.34) he speaks of two compunctions. Achsah, Caleb’s daughter, sits on her donkey in a dry southern land and asks her father for springs of water, and he gives her the upper springs and the lower springs (Judges 1:15). The lower springs are the tears of fear, because we weep at the thought of hell, and the upper springs are the tears of longing for heaven. The lower come first in experience, but the upper are named first because love is higher, and Gregory says that fear, when it is perfected, leads to love.
Bernard of Clairvaux draws the same ladder in On Loving God with three figures: the slave who obeys from fear, the hireling who obeys for reward, and the son who obeys from love. Aquinas gives it technical names: servile fear, initial fear and filial fear (ST II-II, q. 19). Elsewhere Gregory lists four stages in compunction: shame at what the soul has done, fear of what it deserves, awareness of how easily it could fall again today, and longing for the country where sin is no more.
Fear is the door, hope the stairs and love the house.
Finally, the old catechisms ask four things of true sorrow: that it be interior, supernatural, universal and sovereign. Interior means of the heart, and supernatural means that it springs from faith and grace and looks to God, and not merely from embarrassment. Universal means that it reaches every mortal sin without exception, and sovereign means that sin is hated above every other evil. Aquinas explains that sovereign refers to the will’s judgement and does not mean the strongest feeling (Supplement to the Summa, q. 3). That is good news for the scrupulous, who ask whether they feel sorry enough. The question is whether they would rather lose anything than commit the sin again. Keep the word universal in mind, because it is the door through which de Sales walks in a moment.
- Perfect contritionFrom love of God above all. The son; the upper springs; filial fear. With the resolve to confess, it obtains pardon even of mortal sin (CCC 1452).
- Hope risingThe hireling; initial fear. Fear mixed with love, on the way up.
- Imperfect contrition (attrition)From the ugliness of sin or fear of damnation. The slave; the lower springs. A gift that disposes us for absolution (CCC 1453).
- Worldly sorrowRegret folded back on itself. Judas. It produces death (2 Cor 7:10).
Fear is the door, hope the stairs and love the house.
Perfect contrition rises from love of God and imperfect contrition from fear; both are gifts, and they are stages on one road.
4 witnesses: CCC 1451, CCC 1452 and 1453, Council of Trent, Session 14, ch. 4…
Contrition is sorrow of the soul and detestation for the sin committed, together with the resolution not to sin again.
The Church teaches that contrition holds first place among the penitent’s acts. The lecture takes the definition word for word.
The contrition called “imperfect” (or “attrition”) is also a gift of God, a prompting of the Holy Spirit. … By itself however, imperfect contrition cannot obtain the forgiveness of grave sins, but it disposes one to obtain forgiveness in the sacrament of Penance.
The Church teaches that both kinds of sorrow are gifts, and that attrition is completed in the sacrament.
It is a gift of God, and an impulse of the Holy Ghost, who does not indeed as yet dwell in the penitent, but only moves him.
The Council teaches that attrition which excludes the will to sin and hopes for pardon disposes the penitent to receive grace in the sacrament.
The lower spring is given when the soul weeps for fear of punishment; the upper spring when it weeps for longing of the heavenly kingdom.
St Gregory teaches that fear, when it is perfected, leads to love. The wording here is a summary and should be confirmed against a translation.
PonderIf my sorrow is mostly fear, what would help it grow toward love?
How deep the sin goes
Sin has depth, and the Fathers knew it. Augustine, in Sermon 98 and elsewhere, takes the three people Christ raised from the dead as three conditions of the sinner.
- Jairus’s daughter lies dead in the house (Mk 5), which is sin consented to in the heart and not yet carried out.
- The widow’s son is being carried out through the gate of Nain (Lk 7), which is sin brought into act and into the open.
- Lazarus is four days dead and buried in the tomb under a stone (Jn 11), which is sin that has become habit, sealed in by its own weight.
The same Lord raises all three, but the one in the tomb receives the loudest call. John says that Jesus cried out with a loud voice, and preachers have always heard in it the effort of rousing a man buried under habit.
In the Gospel Lazarus comes out still bound, and Jesus says to those standing by, “Unbind him, and let him go.” Augustine hears the Church’s ministry of loosing in that sentence (Mt 18:18; Jn 20:23). The whole sacrament is in the scene: Christ calls, the penitent comes out, and the Church unbinds. The Catechism uses the same picture for the effect of the sacrament, which it calls a true spiritual resurrection (CCC 1468).
Augustine also describes the chain from the inside. In the Confessions (8.5) he says that a perverse will became lust, that lust served became habit, and that habit not resisted became necessity, and that he was held not by another’s iron but by his own iron will. These are links of one chain. The pastoral point is that we should not call a person bound by habit a hypocrite for still struggling. We should tell him that the chain was forged link by link and that it comes off the same way, by grace and by repeated resistance.
- In the house: sin in the heart
- At the gate: sin in the deed
- In the tomb: sin as habit
- “Unbind him”: the Church looses
St Augustine, Sermon 98: the same Lord raises all three, and the deepest needs the loudest call.
Repentance has to reach as deep as the sin, and the sin buried in habit needs the Church to unbind it.
4 witnesses: John 11:43–44, St Augustine, Sermon 98, St Augustine, Confessions VIII.5.10…
He cried with a loud voice, “Lazarus, come out.” The dead man came out, his hands and feet bound with bandages … Jesus said to them, “Unbind him, and let him go.”
Our Lord calls Lazarus out and then gives others the task of unbinding him. St Augustine reads this as the Church’s ministry of loosing.
Three dead were raised by the Lord: one in the house, one carried out through the gate, one buried four days in the tomb.
St Augustine speaks of sin in the heart, in the deed and in habit. The wording here is a summary and should be confirmed.
For of a perverse will came lust; and lust served became custom; and custom not resisted became necessity.
St Augustine confesses that he was bound by his own will. The lecture draws the pastoral lesson that the chain comes off link by link.
Indeed the sacrament of Reconciliation with God brings about a true “spiritual resurrection,” restoration of the dignity and blessings of the life of the children of God, of which the most precious is friendship with God.
The Church teaches that the sacrament raises the soul as Lazarus was raised.
PonderIs there a sin in my life that has moved from the house to the gate, or from the gate to the tomb?
Out of Egypt, but not out of the heart
In the Introduction to the Devout Life, Part I, de Sales sets out two purifications. The first, in chapter 6, is from mortal sin itself, and its means is the sacrament of penance, which is why he urges a general confession at the start (chapter 19 shows how to make one). The second, in chapter 7, is from all sinful affections. In chapter 5 he reminds us that the soul rising out of sin is like the dawn, which does not banish the darkness at once but by degrees, so the second purification is not an instant event.
His text says that all the children of Israel went out of Egypt, but not all went out heartily, and so in the desert some of them sighed after the leeks and onions and the fleshpots of Egypt. Numbers 11 adds fish, cucumbers, melons and garlic, and Exodus 16 has the pots of meat. Notice what they remembered and what they forgot. They remembered the food and forgot the whip. A half-repentant heart edits its past in exactly this way.
De Sales is sharp about such penitents. They abstain for a while, but reluctantly. They would like to be able to sin without being damned. They talk about their old deeds with a lingering taste, and they envy those who are still indulging. He adds the woman who has given up a life of sin but still takes delight in being sought after and admired. His second image is of people who are not ill and yet are pale and sickly, languid in all they do, eating without appetite, sleeping without refreshment and laughing without mirth. That is the soul that has stopped sinning and has not yet started living.
He names the cost. There is the danger of relapse, and there is weakness, because these affections enfeeble the mind and weigh it down, so that it cannot be ready, diligent and frequent in good works. In chapter 1 he had already made this point with a picture of flight: half-hearted people fly rarely, slowly and heavily, while the devout rise often on a swift, soaring wing. Devotion, for him, is promptness.
Then comes the line that ties back to the four qualities of contrition. A penitent who hates sin with a feeble but sincere contrition resolves not to sin again. A penitent who hates it with a hearty, vigorous contrition detests not only the sin but every affection, circumstance and inducement that leads to it. That is universal sorrow in action.
Some questions to put to ourselves, which are an application and not de Sales’s own words:
- Do I still envy?
- Do I tell the old stories with relish?
- Do I keep a door ajar, just in case?
More than a thousand years before de Sales, John Cassian wrote the same teaching down in Conference 20, On the End of Penitence and the Marks of Satisfaction, where Abba Pinufius answers a question about how we can know we are forgiven. The proof of satisfaction and pardon, he says, is to have expelled the love of our sins from our hearts (ch. 5). A man is not yet free as long as images of those sins dance before his eyes. Later (ch. 7) he says that when, in the midst of tears and labour, the memory fades and the thorns of conscience are drawn out by God’s grace, the man has reached the end of satisfaction.
Cassian is also realistic. In chapter 12 he says that this ending applies to the capital sins. For the small offences into which we fall every day, since the just man falls seven times, penitence never ceases. I would add a caution for the scrupulous: the mere return of a memory is not a sin. The question is whether the heart consents and delights.
- Leaving Egypt
- Mortal sin renounced
- By the sacrament
- Begun with a general confession
- Forgetting the leeks and onions
- Affections uprooted
- By degrees, like the dawn
- Ends when even the memory no longer haunts
Feeble contrition resolves not to sin; hearty contrition detests every affection and inducement that leads to it.
The first purification is from sin; the second is from the love of it, and it comes by degrees, like the dawn.
4 witnesses: St Francis de Sales, Introduction to the Devout Life I.7, Numbers 11:5, St John Cassian, Conferences XX.5…
All the Israelites went forth from Egypt, but not all went forth heartily, and so in the wilderness many of them sighed for the onions and fleshpots of Egypt.
St Francis de Sales speaks of penitents who have left sin in body but not in heart. Wording differs by translation and should be confirmed.
We remember the fish we ate in Egypt for nothing, the cucumbers, the melons, the leeks, the onions, and the garlic.
Scripture records what the people remembered of Egypt; they spoke of the food and not of their slavery.
This is the proof of satisfaction and pardon: that we have expelled the love of our sins from our hearts.
St John Cassian teaches the same as St Francis de Sales, many centuries earlier. The wording is a summary and should be confirmed.
For a righteous man falls seven times, and rises again.
Scripture speaks of the just man who falls and rises, which is why penitence for small faults never ends.
PonderWhich of de Sales’s three questions is hardest for me to answer honestly?
Not yet, a thread, and an empty house
Three saints describe from the inside what de Sales describes from the outside. Augustine, in Confessions 8.7, prays for chastity and continence, “but not yet,” because he fears that God will hear him too quickly and cure a desire he would rather satisfy. That is the half-repentant prayer in a few words. Teresa of Avila, in chapters 7 and 8 of her Life, describes years of a divided heart. Among worldly pleasures she remembered what she owed God, and in prayer her worldly affections troubled her, so that she enjoyed neither. She says she does not know how she bore it for a month, never mind for years.
John of the Cross gives the sharpest image, in the Ascent of Mount Carmel (I.11). A bird held by a thin thread is as grounded as one held by a cord, as long as the thread is not broken. The thread is easier to break, he says, but however easy it is, the bird cannot fly until it is broken. This answers the person who says it is only one small thing. It also carries good news, because a thread is much easier to break than a cord.
Gregory the Great puts the same problem in the Pastoral Rule (III.30), for those who weep over their sins and do not leave them. He quotes Sirach: what good is it to wash after touching a dead body if you touch it again (Sir 34:25)? Gregory’s warning is against tears that are never followed by a change of life.
Jesus tells a short parable that every penitent should know (Mt 12:43–45; Lk 11:24–26). The unclean spirit leaves a man, wanders through dry places, and then decides to return to the house he left. He finds it empty, swept, and put in order, and he brings seven other spirits worse than himself. Everything has been done except filling it. The lesson is that a vice must be replaced by a practice: prayer at the hour you used to sin, a good friend where the old company used to be, a work of service in the evening that used to be wasted. The second purification is built by what we put in, and not only by what we throw out.
Ignatius adds a lesson about the enemy’s tactics in the Rules for the Discernment of Spirits of the First Week. For people who go from sin to sin, he says, the enemy offers apparent pleasures, and the good spirit uses the opposite method and stings the conscience with remorse [314]. Then he gives three images.
- In rule twelve [325] the enemy is weak when resisted and fierce when yielded to. Commentators usually call him a bully, though Ignatius’s own comparison is to someone quarrelling.
- In rule thirteen [326] he is like a false lover who wants everything kept secret and who loses his hold once the matter is told to a confessor or a director.
- In rule fourteen [327] he is like a commander who studies the fortress and attacks the weakest wall.
The lessons are plain: resist firmly at the start, say it aloud, and guard the weak wall, which means knowing your own time, place, company and mood.
Psalm 32 gives the same argument from the other side. While the psalmist kept silence, his bones wasted away, and when he acknowledged his sin to the Lord, the guilt was forgiven (Ps 32:3–5). The sin kept secret grows, and the sin told shrinks. That is one reason the confessional is spoken and not merely thought.
A thread holds the bird as surely as a cord, and a house swept but left empty is reoccupied: repentance must break the last bond and fill the space.
4 witnesses: St Augustine, Confessions VIII.7.17, St John of the Cross, Ascent of Mount Carmel I.11.4, Matthew 12:44–45…
Give me chastity and continence, but not yet.
St Augustine confesses that he feared God would hear him too soon. The lecture takes it as the half-repentant prayer.
It comes to the same thing whether a bird be held by a slender cord or by a stout one; since, even if it be slender, the bird will be as well held as though it were stout, for so long as it breaks it not and flies not away.
St John of the Cross teaches that any attachment, however slight, keeps the soul from flight until it is broken.
And when he comes he finds it empty, swept, and put in order. Then he goes and brings with him seven other spirits more evil than himself.
Our Lord warns that a house cleared and left empty is reoccupied. The lecture draws the lesson that a vice must be replaced by a practice.
He acts like a false lover who wishes to remain hidden and not be revealed … when the matter is revealed to a good confessor or to another spiritual person, he is very much displeased.
St Ignatius teaches that the enemy loses his hold when temptations are told to a confessor or director.
PonderWhat “one small thing” am I keeping, and what good practice could take its place?
The second plank, and Dante’s gate
Now we can speak of the sacrament itself. Tertullian is the first writer we know to call penance the second plank, secunda tabula, and Jerome uses the phrase too. Baptism is the ship, sin after baptism is the shipwreck, and penance is the plank you hold. Trent and the Catechism take it up (CCC 1446). Trent adds that the Fathers called penance a laborious baptism, because here the penitent’s own effort in sorrow and satisfaction is called for. John Climacus, in step 5 of the Ladder, calls repentance a renewal of baptism and a contract with God for a second life. Ambrose says the Church has both water and tears: “the water of baptism and the tears of repentance” (CCC 1429). The mercy is the same, and what differs is the price.
Origen lists seven ways by which sins are forgiven in the Homilies on Leviticus (2.4): baptism, martyrdom, almsgiving, forgiving those who wrong us, converting a sinner, great love, and finally penance, which he calls hard and laborious, when the sinner washes his bed with tears and is not ashamed to make known his sin to the priest of the Lord and to seek a remedy. The warning in Origen is that people sometimes choose the door that costs least. Almsgiving is good and forgiving others is good, and neither replaces the door that the Church has actually opened for the sins of the baptised.
The Catechism says what this door leads to. The whole power of the sacrament lies in restoring us to God’s grace and joining us with him in intimate friendship, and the usual result for those who receive it well is peace and serenity of conscience with strong spiritual consolation (CCC 1468). It also reconciles us with the Church (1469). So we return to Lazarus: Christ calls us out, and the Church unbinds us.
If you want a way to learn the order of a confession, I know no better picture than the ninth canto of Dante’s Purgatorio. Dante comes to a gate reached by three steps.
- The first is white marble, polished so that he sees himself reflected in it. That is the examination of conscience, since you cannot confess what you have not looked at.
- The second is dark, rough and cracked lengthwise and across. That is the broken and contrite heart (Ps 51:17).
- The third is porphyry, blazing red like blood spurting from a vein. That is love and satisfaction, and the blood of Christ behind them.
At the top an angel sits on the threshold with a drawn sword. Dante throws himself at his feet, asks for mercy, and strikes his breast three times, as we do at the Confiteor. The angel traces seven letters P on his forehead with the sword. The P stands for peccata, sins, and one will be erased at each terrace of the mountain.
The angel holds two keys, gold and silver. The gold is the dearer, and the silver needs great skill and wisdom before it will turn. Readers have taken these as authority and discernment: the confessor needs the power to absolve and the skill to untie the knot. And the angel says that Peter told him to err on the side of opening the gate rather than keeping it shut, if people only throw themselves at his feet.
- White mirror: examination
- Cracked stone: contrition
- At the angel’s feet: confession
- Two keys: absolution
- Red stone: satisfaction
Contrition, confession and satisfaction are the penitent’s acts; absolution is the Church’s (Purgatorio IX).
Penance is the second plank after shipwreck: the same mercy as baptism, now costing tears.
4 witnesses: CCC 1446, CCC 1429, citing St Ambrose, Letter 41.12, Origen, Homilies on Leviticus 2.4…
It is this sacrament that the Fathers of the Church present as “the second plank [of salvation] after the shipwreck which is the loss of grace.”
The Church takes up the image of the Fathers. Penance is offered to the baptised who have lost grace by sin.
There are water and tears: the water of Baptism and the tears of repentance.
St Ambrose speaks of the Church’s two remedies for sin. The lecture quotes his words through the Catechism.
There is yet a seventh, though hard and laborious, remission of sins through penance, when the sinner washes his couch with tears … and is not ashamed to declare his sin to the priest of the Lord and seek a remedy.
Origen is an early ecclesiastical writer, not a canonised Father. His seventh remission is the one the lecture warns us not to avoid.
The sacrifice acceptable to God is a broken spirit; a broken and contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise.
Scripture tells us that the contrite heart is the offering God accepts. Dante’s cracked step is drawn from this verse.
PonderWhich of Dante’s three steps do I tend to skip when I go to confession?
Who is on the other side
The Catechism gives the confessor four faces (CCC 1465). He acts as:
- the Good Shepherd who seeks the lost sheep,
- the Good Samaritan who binds up wounds,
- the Father who awaits the prodigal son and welcomes him,
- and the just judge whose judgement is both just and merciful.
Then it gives the limit: he is not the master of God’s forgiveness but its servant (1466). The Church also protects the penitent. A priest who hears confessions is bound under very severe penalties to absolute secrecy about the sins confessed (1467).
Faustina’s Diary puts it from the Lord’s side. In 1448 she is told to point souls to the Tribunal of Mercy, where the greatest miracles take place and are constantly repeated, and where it suffices to come in faith to the feet of the Lord’s representative and reveal one’s misery. In 975 she is told to pray that souls will not be afraid to approach it. Elsewhere in the Diary the Lord says that he himself is waiting in the confessional, hidden only by the priest, and that he himself acts in the soul. For anyone ashamed to tell sins to a man, this is the answer: you are telling them to the one who is waiting.
Ambrose says of Peter that tears wash away what it is shameful to confess aloud. This does not replace sacramental confession, which the Church requires for grave sins (CCC 1456), but it is true about what tears do. John Climacus, in step 5 of the Ladder, calls repentance the daughter of hope and the renunciation of despair, and in step 7 he writes of joy-making mourning, a sorrow that gladdens.
Then the tradition restores proportion. Isaac the Syrian compares the sins of all flesh to a handful of sand thrown into the great sea of God’s mercy. A saying attributed to the Curé of Ars sets our sins as grains of sand beside the mountain of mercy. Thérèse of Lisieux says that if she had every possible crime on her conscience she would still go to God with confidence, because a multitude of offences would be like a drop of water in a blazing furnace. In Manuscript A she adds that Jesus has forgiven her more than Magdalene, because he forgave her in advance by keeping her from falling, as a doctor might remove the stone from the road before his child can trip. These images do not license sin, since de Sales insists that the affection for sin must go. They answer despair.
There is an opposite error, and de Sales names it in Part III, chapter 9, on gentleness toward ourselves. It is reasonable to be displeased at our faults, he says, but we must guard against a bitter, angry or peevish displeasure. He notes the absurdity of being angry that we were angry, and says such irritation springs from self-love disturbed at its own imperfection and feeds pride. What we want is a quiet, steady, firm displeasure. A judge who sentences calmly punishes better than one in a rage, and a calm and lasting repentance corrects better than a passionate one. We should speak to our own heart as a parent speaks to a child: poor heart, fallen again so soon, get up and go on.
Pope Francis put the point in one line:
The Lord never tires of forgiving us; we are the ones who tire of seeking his mercy.
Judas is the warning, Peter is the answer, and the difference between them is whether the sorrow ran toward the Father.
The priest is shepherd, Samaritan, father and judge, the servant of a mercy so great that our sins are sand thrown into the sea.
4 witnesses: CCC 1465 and 1466, St Faustina Kowalska, Diary 1602, St Isaac the Syrian, Ascetical Homilies…
When he celebrates the sacrament of Penance, the priest is fulfilling the ministry of the Good Shepherd who seeks the lost sheep, of the Good Samaritan who binds up wounds, of the Father who awaits the prodigal son and welcomes him on his return, and of the just and impartial judge … The confessor is not the master of God’s forgiveness, but its servant.
The Church teaches that the confessor serves a forgiveness that is God’s, never his own.
When you go to confession, know this, that I Myself am waiting there for you. I am only hidden by the priest, but I Myself act in your soul.
St Faustina writes that the Lord himself waits in the confessional. The paragraph number and wording should be confirmed against the Diary.
As a handful of sand thrown into the great sea, so are the sins of all flesh in comparison with the mind of God.
St Isaac restores proportion for the discouraged penitent. The homily number and wording should be confirmed.
The Lord never tires of forgiving us; we are the ones who tire of seeking his mercy.
Pope Francis teaches that the limit is never on God’s side. The lecture takes it as the answer to despair.
PonderIs my difficulty with confession more often shame, despair or anger at myself, and which image here answers it?
Repair, replace, and return often
Many sins wrong a neighbour, and the Catechism says plainly that one must do what is possible to repair the harm: return stolen goods, restore the good name of someone slandered, make good the injuries done. Simple justice requires as much (CCC 1459). Zacchaeus is the Gospel’s example. He gives half his goods to the poor and repays fourfold anyone he has cheated, and Jesus says that salvation has come to his house (Lk 19:8–9). Jesus also tells us that if we remember at the altar that a brother has something against us, we must leave the gift and first be reconciled (Mt 5:23–24).
The penance the confessor gives is meant to fit the penitent’s situation and to serve his good, as a remedy for sin and a help to renew life (CCC 1460). It is small on purpose. The Catechism says that the interior penance of the Christian is expressed above all in fasting, prayer and almsgiving, and also in daily gestures of reconciliation, concern for the poor, admitting faults, fraternal correction, examination of conscience and spiritual direction (1434 and 1435). Here the empty house meets the sacrament, because satisfaction is what fills the house.
The Catechism says that deliberate and unrepented venial sin disposes us little by little to commit mortal sin (CCC 1863), and that every sin, even venial, involves an unhealthy attachment to creatures that must be purified here on earth or after death in Purgatory (1472). Confession of venial sins is not strictly required, but the Church strongly recommends it, because it helps us to form a correct conscience, to fight evil tendencies, to be healed by Christ and to progress in the life of the Spirit (1458). Confession of grave sins is required at least once a year (1457).
You will recognise here de Sales’s second purification, John of the Cross’s thread and Cassian’s daily penitence in the language of the Catechism. De Sales devotes a whole chapter to the need for purging even the tendency to venial sin (Part I, ch. 22). The confessional is the regular, humble place where we take hold of the thread and cut a little more of it. Seen this way, the second purification is done in small instalments, and frequent confession is how we pay them.
Satisfaction repairs what we broke and puts a good practice where the sin was, and frequent confession cuts the thread a little at a time.
3 witnesses: CCC 1459, Luke 19:8–9, CCC 1458
One must do what is possible in order to repair the harm (e.g., return stolen goods, restore the reputation of someone slandered, pay compensation for injuries). Simple justice requires as much.
The Church teaches that absolution takes away sin but does not remedy all the disorders sin has caused, so the penitent must make amends.
Behold, Lord, the half of my goods I give to the poor; and if I have defrauded any one of anything, I restore it fourfold. And Jesus said to him, “Today salvation has come to this house.”
Scripture gives Zacchaeus as the example of repentance that repairs. His restitution comes from joy at being received.
Without being strictly necessary, confession of everyday faults (venial sins) is nevertheless strongly recommended by the Church. Indeed the regular confession of our venial sins helps us form our conscience, fight against evil tendencies, let ourselves be healed by Christ and progress in the life of the Spirit.
The Church recommends frequent confession as a means of growth, which the lecture links to St Francis de Sales’s second purification.
PonderIs there a harm I have done that I could still repair, and how often do I go to confession?
The father who interrupts the speech
The Catechism reads the parable of the prodigal son as the pattern of conversion (CCC 1439). The son’s illusion of freedom, the far country, the hunger among the pigs, the humiliation, the memory of what he has lost, the decision to confess, the journey home, the welcome and the father’s joy are all marks of the process.
In Luke 15 the son comes to himself (v. 17), resolves “I will arise and go” (v. 18), and rehearses a speech whose last clause asks to be treated as a hired servant (v. 19). The father sees him while he is still far off, runs, embraces and kisses him. The son begins the speech: “Father, I have sinned against heaven and before you; I am no longer worthy to be called your son.” And the father breaks in with the robe, the ring, the sandals and the feast, and the clause about the hired servant is never said (v. 21).
Everything we have studied is in this story. There is examination (“he came to himself”), contrition, resolution, confession, absolution, and restoration given before any penance. There is also the elder brother, who stayed at home and cannot rejoice in mercy, and he is a warning to those of us who have never left.
So go away with five images: Peter’s look, the leeks and onions of Egypt, the thread on the bird, the second plank, and the father who interrupts. The sinner who goes to the Father is met before the speech is finished.
- The far country
- He came to himself
- “I will arise and go”
- The father runs
- The speech cut short
- Robe, ring, feast
Examination, contrition, confession and absolution, with restoration given before any penance (CCC 1439; Lk 15:11–32).
Mercy is quicker than our confession: the father runs to meet the son and cuts the speech short.
3 witnesses: Luke 15:21–22, CCC 1439, Psalm 32:5
Father, I have sinned against heaven and before you; I am no longer worthy to be called your son. But the father said to his servants, “Bring quickly the best robe, and put it on him.”
Our Lord tells of a father who does not let the son finish his rehearsed speech. The request to be a hired servant (v. 19) is never spoken.
The process of conversion and repentance was described by Jesus in the parable of the prodigal son, the center of which is the merciful father.
The Church teaches that the parable maps the whole movement of conversion, and that its centre is the father.
I acknowledged my sin to thee, and I did not hide my iniquity; I said, “I will confess my transgressions to the Lord”; then thou didst forgive the guilt of my sin.
Scripture tells of forgiveness given as soon as the sin is acknowledged, as the father welcomes the son at the first words.
PonderAm I more like the younger son rehearsing his speech, or the elder brother who cannot rejoice?
The images at a glance
| Image | Source | What it teaches |
|---|---|---|
| Peter and Judas | Lk 22:61–62; Mt 27:3–5; 2 Cor 7:10 | The same sorrow, pointed in opposite directions |
| Achsah’s two springs | St Gregory the Great, Dialogues III.34 | Fear comes first; love is higher |
| Slave, hireling, son | St Bernard, On Loving God | Sorrow grows from fear through hope to love |
| Three dead raised | St Augustine, Sermon 98 | Sin in the heart, in the deed and in habit |
| Leeks, onions and fleshpots | St Francis de Sales, Introduction I.7 | Leaving sin is not yet leaving the love of it |
| The bird on a thread | St John of the Cross, Ascent I.11 | A small attachment still keeps the soul from flight |
| The swept, empty house | Mt 12:43–45 | Repentance must fill as well as clear |
| The false lover | St Ignatius, Spiritual Exercises [326] | The sin told loses its power |
| The second plank | Tertullian; CCC 1446 | The mercy of baptism, now costing tears |
| Dante’s gate | Purgatorio IX | Examination, contrition, confession, absolution, satisfaction |
| Sand in the sea | St Isaac the Syrian; St Thérèse | Sin is small against mercy |
| The interrupted speech | Lk 15:21; CCC 1439 | Mercy is quicker than our confession |
Study it
For a group or on your own. Tick each question as you answer it; your ticks stay on this device.
- Peter and Judas were both sorry; godly sorrow turns toward the Father, and worldly sorrow folds in on itself (2 Cor 7:10).
- Repentance is a turning of the whole life to God, begun by his grace (CCC 1431 and 1432).
- The penitent brings contrition, confession and satisfaction; the Church gives absolution.
- Perfect contrition comes from love of God and imperfect contrition from fear; both are gifts, and attrition is completed in the sacrament.
- Sin deepens from the heart to the deed to habit, and repentance must reach as deep as the sin.
- Leaving sin is the first purification; losing the love of it is the second, and it comes by degrees.
- A house swept but left empty is reoccupied, so a vice must be replaced by a practice, and the sin told loses its power.
- Penance is the second plank after shipwreck, given through a priest who serves God’s forgiveness, and the Father meets us before the speech is finished.
“But while he was yet at a distance, his father saw him and had compassion, and ran and embraced him and kissed him.”Luke 15:20
O my God, I am heartily sorry for having offended Thee, and I detest all my sins because of Thy just punishments, but most of all because they offend Thee, my God, who art all good and deserving of all my love. I firmly resolve, with the help of Thy grace, to sin no more and to avoid the near occasion of sin. Amen.
Act of Contrition
← LecturesLecture 06