← Faith, Reason and Truth

Gettier, Aquinas and the Certainty of Faith

From my notes · 1 min read · Reflection

I was reading about the Gettier problem in epistemology, which challenges the classical definition of knowledge as “justified true belief.”

Then I came across the Thomistic understanding of knowledge as “the adequation of the intellect to the thing” that is, truth as the deep correspondence between the mind and reality. And further in his Summa:

“Faith is more certain than all human knowledge, because it is founded on the very truth of God.”

I literally applauded.

There is nothing on earth that rivals the philosophical, theological, and spiritual treasury of the Catholic Church. The Holy Spirit is the reason.

I’m not nearly sophisticated enough to write more on this, but if you sponsor a theology course for me at Holy Apostles Seminary, I promise I’ll come back and teach it to you myself!

But I will say this: what all of this helped me see, something I already knew, but now with much sharper clarity, is that people often mistake accidentally confirmed interpretations for true knowledge.

That’s how superstitions form. Take the classic example: “Black cats bring bad luck.” You see a black cat, and by pure coincidence something unfortunate happens. Suddenly, the pattern seems confirmed. But this isn’t knowledge, it’s a cognitive shortcut built on a logical fallacy, not on a real grasp of truth.

What we call “knowledge” in many cases is just unquestioned interpretation, reinforced by coincidence. And without a solid foundation, philosophically, theologically, and spiritually, we’ll keep mistaking error for insight, insight that will not only ruin our chances at discovering truth about the physical world, but will devastate our spiritual lives as well.

Many people live with deeply self-destructive spiritualities, built on these faulty paradigms. Worse still, some take pride in them, making it nearly impossible to receive reason or sound counsel.

Conversation

No one has written yet. Share what this stirred in you.

Every comment is read before it appears.
Faith, Reason and Truth#epistemology#aquinas#truth
Read alongsideConsumed · Trials in Prayer, Call to Virtue and More Dangers of SinOpen the chapter, with its witnesses →
All notes →