Chapter Seven
My Poverty, God’s Mercy
“The LORD upholds all who are falling, and raises up all who are bowed down.”Psalm 145:143
It is easy to say many beautiful things about God, and to counsel others to “look to God and persevere even when it is painful.” But when we ourselves face even the slightest difficulty, we often fold. A priest once asked me in confession: “Why do you sound surprised that you sinned?” That question has remained with me ever since. I should be shocked that I was ever able to cooperate with grace to resist any sin at all. I should never be shocked by my falls. Rather, I should be humble before God, because this is my condition and has always been my condition: weakness and the wounds of sin. Only God has the power and the means to lift me from it, to set my feet again on the path of righteousness and holiness. Therefore, I must detest sin, because it resists the work of God in me and brings death into my soul. But I must not become despondent, even when the struggle to practice virtue is difficult. Instead, I must come to God with confidence every time, humbling myself and admitting my sins.3
God gives. I receive. He is rich in mercy. I am poor without it. That is the true order of reality. And so I must always look up to God, and also to those whom God places in my path, because they too are instruments through whom He gives grace to my soul and help to my body.3
One of the problems of our times is the error of overcorrecting in the case of a perceived problem. Like too much scrupulosity and rigidity is overcorrected with laxity. And we see this in the way we treat sin. Mortal sins are horrible ruptures with God and should be called its proper name: Death. However at the same time, we must have in mind that what the Lord has given us is life, and this life is always available to us whenever we need it. This is the balance. Mortal sins are evil, but God’s love which comes to meet us at every moment of our lives, especially in our vulnerability is more powerful than death. Therefore, if you fall into this death of mortal sin, repent immediately and resolve to redouble your efforts to prevent any future fall. Which redoubling means using every means at your disposal to engage more decisively in the spiritual combat, the chief of which is the Eucharist paired with regular confession. So, do not linger in self-pity or delay conversion. Act at once. Again, remember that God is always ready to welcome you back no matter how many times you have fallen in the past. I want to reiterate this: You and I cannot conquer our weaknesses by sheer willpower, we need the grace of God and He has made them all available to us in the Sacraments. So our primary “effort” will be in receiving what He freely gives to us and in practicing constant prayer, fasting and almsgiving, the three powerful weapons against pride, lust, greed and other capital sins.4
If, however, the sexual sin is with an illicit partner or one with whom there’s no chance of marriage, then the relationship must be ended completely and without delay. There is no room for negotiation here. Do not remain friends. Do not continue conversations. Do not preserve emotional ties. Distance is not cruelty; it is mercy. What often disguises itself as compassion or consideration can easily become a tool of temptation. Lust thrives on familiarity. The best way to fight sexual sins is to remove yourself from anything that leads to it, this is the first and most basic practical remedy, without which prayer, fasting, and almsgiving are often weakened. If one prays, receives communion, goes to confession regularly but clings to everything that leads them to sin it would be more difficult than it needs to be to separate oneself from this sin. The spiritual masters are nearly unanimous on this point: run. For instance Don Lorenzo Scupoli says in his classic “Spiritual Combat”: “First, you must not war against this vice by confronting it, but, on the contrary, by fleeing with all your might from the thing or person that may have the least likelihood of exciting it”3
There is usually a knowable and intelligible reason why God commands us to do certain things and forbids others. Granted, we cannot fully understand the reason behind every law of God, but every command is good and ordered toward our flourishing. God does not command arbitrarily. His laws are given so that we may become like Him, for His plan is not merely that we obey, but that we be transformed. The end of this transformation is heaven, where we shall see Him as He is and be made like Him. So why is fornication, and other illicit sexual acts, sinful? Fundamentally, because they depart from their purpose and therefore draw man away from his true end. Sexuality has an objective meaning given by God. Man does not exist to indulge his appetites without restraint. Whenever man allows himself to be governed by his carnal appetites, rather than by reason enlightened by grace, he is led toward death, not life.3
To begin answering this, we must first ask a more basic question: what is a shoe for? Once we understand the purpose of a thing, we can determine what we truly need. We ask this question within the larger questions of who we are and what we are for. It is, in a sense, a question within a question. If the purpose of a thing helps us determine what we need, it also helps us recognize when that need has already been met. When the need is satisfied, only a modest margin beyond it is justified. Everything far beyond that ceases to be proper use and becomes misuse. Some may disagree with this principle, and that is fine. But it is very difficult to deny that straying too far into excess after genuine need has already been met is sinful, because it is a misuse of the gifts God has given. This is not something most of us like to admit to ourselves. It is difficult to see how someone who sincerely desires heaven could justify owning ten personal cars under normal circumstances. Of course, there could be exceptions, for instance if owning more were tied to one’s livelihood. This is my prudential judgment, and you are free to disagree with the exact number. But even if you do, you must still face the question. Choose your own number. Be specific. Justify it. Do not leave it vague. Pray about it. Ultimately, what we are trying to discover is not what we prefer, but what God wants for each of us. Giving free rein to every desire leads to destruction. Therefore, we must learn to ask, with everything we possess, how much is too much.3
I recall an anecdote of a man who woke every day at 5 a.m. to attend Mass. His one persistent prayer was for a car. Month after month, he prayed. Eventually, God granted it. He bought a beautiful car. And then every morning at 5 a.m., instead of going to Mass, he woke to wash it. When material things become the motive of our pursuit of God, we will fail. Only the love of God can sustain the spiritual life. Other desires may bring us to His door initially, but we must grow beyond them. Like the disciples, we must move from curiosity about the miracle-worker, to expecting bread for our hunger, and finally to the deeper surrender that says: “Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life.”3
Sin should bring us closer to God. Our awareness of our sinfulness should have us running to God every chance we get. Saint Francis de Sales, quoting another, says there are two who need God’s grace: the strong, so they remain strong; and the weak, so they become strong; the well, so they remain well; and the sick, so they are made well. So even the holy man runs to God desperately, because he knows what he is capable of, that “apart from Me you can do nothing”. Without Christ, he cannot do any good ordered to eternal life, and he easily turns toward sin. We must learn from their zeal to receive and be with Christ, to hunger for Christ when He is “far,” and to rejoice in His presence when He is “near,” meaning sacramentally, since Christ is always with us.2