Kenneth C. AlimbaBooks

The Juggler and the ChildrenA Guide to Seeking the True God

Chapter Two

Logical Entailments

7 passages · 25 witnesses
We are horrible at seeing the hidden implications of our actions and convictions. The things we do and believe never stand alone. They contain other truths within them or are linked directly to other truths or other ideas. This means that if the thing we believe is true, there must be other things that must be true around that truth we believe.4
For instance, if we say Jesus is God, the direct implication is that Mary is Mother of God since Jesus is a Person: the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity, and Mary is His mother from whom He took flesh. So if a person says Mary is not Mother of God, they are implying Jesus is not God. Those two things cannot be logically untangled, they are permanently tied together, that to reject one necessarily is to reject the other.5
But for a simpler example if we say that all men are mortal, and Kenneth is a man, we are saying that Kenneth is mortal. If the first statement is true, the implication or entailment that follows must also be true. Kenneth cannot be both man who is mortal, and immortal at the same time. That is a contradiction. It is like arguing that there is a square circle or that some bachelors are married. Those are contradictions and are necessarily false.4
So when we judge our actions or thoughts we are prone to committing similar logical fallacies that cause us to believe falsehoods, and it is made worse when we refuse to test what we believe.3
What I am sketching here is what is called logical entailment in philosophy which is a way of saying that if X is true, Y must be true, not by opinion, mere association or interpretation but by necessity. Necessity means something like that 2 plus 2 must always be 4 of necessity. So even though we can imagine a universe where a cat barks, and a dog meows, we cannot logically imagine one where 2 plus 2 equals anything other than 4 since this is a necessary truth.3
This is the strongest relationship a truth can have to another, so the logical entailment of anything we believe can be many, and sometimes we cannot see them all, and that is fine. But once we come to a point where we cannot reconcile two logically contradictory things, we must make adjustments in our conclusions or risk being the juggler again. Truth demands such an adjustment.3
Where there is no real contradiction at the level of logical entailment, but we sense a real tension between what we believe and the implication that is attached to it, we should investigate further rather than ignoring it, again, we do not want to be the juggler.3
Remember today

Test everything; hold fast what is good.

1 Thessalonians 5:21
Pray

Come, Holy Spirit, fill the hearts of your faithful and kindle in them the fire of your love. Send forth your Spirit and they shall be created, and you shall renew the face of the earth. O God, who by the light of the Holy Spirit did instruct the hearts of the faithful, grant that by the same Holy Spirit we may be truly wise and ever enjoy His consolations. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.Prayer to the Holy Spirit, traditional

Next · Story and TruthContinue →
Scripture quotations are from the RSV-CE. Quotes marked “to confirm” await checking against their editions.