- Our judgments are acts in us, but they respond to realities we do not create.
- Because we can be wrong about what is good, there must be a goodness about which we can be wrong.
- Whatever exists, insofar as it exists, is good; truth, goodness, beauty, justice and love converge in being.
- Everything the creature has, it has received; God does not have being and goodness, He is Being and Goodness itself.
- Created goods are real but finite: sought out of order, or asked to be God, they become destructive.
- The many goods form one web because they come from one source, in whom every perfection is perfectly one.
- Being finite and temporal, we can know God truly but never comprehend or judge Him from outside.
- Our proper posture is reception, and the more rightly ordered we become, the more clearly we see what is.
We usually say or think that a thing is beautiful, that an action is in accord with justice, that something done proceeds from love, or that something is good. Often we agree with others that this or that is beautiful. Other times we disagree. We agree that an action is just, and other times we disagree.
Sometimes we agree even when our definitions differ. Other times our definitions are the same, but we still disagree about what we are actually looking at. Yet beneath all these judgments there is something remarkable. In all of them, we are signaling something that is not reducible to the act of judging itself.
Our judgment does not create the reality we judge
When I say, “This is beautiful,” I am not merely saying, “I happen to like this.” When I say, “This is just,” I am not merely saying, “I have a feeling of approval toward this.” I am appealing to something in the thing.
There is some reality, some intelligible feature, some order, perfection, or relation in what I am contemplating that makes my judgment intelligible. My judgment is in me, but what the judgment is about is not necessarily created by me.
This is true even when the judgment is expressed subjectively. If I say, “I love this,” there is certainly a subjective component. I am reporting something about my own interior response. I desire it. I delight in it. I am attracted to it. But the very intelligibility of this response raises another question: what is it about the thing that makes it capable of arousing this desire or delight in the first place?
The subject is responding to the object. It is similar to saying, “I see blue.” The seeing is an act occurring in me, but I do not create the blue thing simply by seeing it. The subjective experience is real, but its intelligibility depends upon something being presented to the subject.
We encounter goodness, truth, and beauty through subjective acts of seeing, thinking, desiring, and judging. But those acts do not manufacture the realities to which they respond. Subjectivity does not imply subjectivism.
- Me: I see, think, feel. These are acts happening in me; they are subjective.
- My judgment: “This is good.” “This is beautiful.” “This is just.” The judgment is in me; it is my response.
- The thing, reality: something real in itself. It exists whether or not I judge it.
We make judgments in our minds, but they are about real things outside us that exist independently of our judgment. Key point: my judgment is in me; what it is about is not created by me.
My judgment is in me, but what the judgment is about is not created by me.
2 witnesses: Wisdom 13:5, Romans 1:20
For from the greatness and beauty of created things comes a corresponding perception of their Creator.
Scripture speaks of beauty as something really in created things, which the mind perceives rather than invents.
Ever since the creation of the world his invisible nature, namely, his eternal power and deity, has been clearly perceived in the things that have been made.
St Paul reminds us that our perceiving is a response to what is truly there in the things that have been made.
PonderWhen you say “I love this,” what are you saying about yourself, and what are you saying about the thing?
Error does not destroy objectivity
If goodness were nothing more than my subjective response to something, then I could never truly be wrong about goodness. Whatever I desired would simply be good because I desired it. But that is not how we ordinarily understand moral error. We say, “I thought this was good, but I was wrong.” That statement only makes sense if my perception of goodness can fail to correspond to goodness itself.
The same is true of beauty. Someone can say, “This is beautiful,” and later, after greater understanding, realize that what attracted him was merely superficial. Another person can fail to recognize something genuinely beautiful because of the state of his own mind, education, desires, or character. None of this establishes that beauty is subjective. It establishes that our apprehension of beauty is fallible.
Fallibility of perception does not imply subjectivity of the object. A mistaken judgment is evidence of a gap between perception and reality, not evidence that reality is created by perception.
My eyes can misperceive color, but that does not make color imaginary. My intellect can misunderstand an argument, but that does not make truth subjective. My judgment can mistake an apparent good for a real good, but that does not make goodness subjective. My aesthetic judgment can be poorly formed, but that does not make beauty subjective.
Indeed, the possibility of error points in the opposite direction. If I can be mistaken about what is good, there must be some distinction between my judgment and the reality toward which my judgment is directed. We encounter truth, goodness, and beauty. We respond to them. We participate in them. But we do not create them simply by recognizing them.
| What can err | How it errs | What does not follow |
|---|---|---|
| My eyes | They can misperceive color | Color is imaginary |
| My intellect | It can misunderstand an argument | Truth is subjective |
| My moral judgment | It can mistake an apparent good for a real good | Goodness is subjective |
| My aesthetic judgment | It can be poorly formed | Beauty is subjective |
A mistaken judgment shows a gap between perception and reality, not that perception creates reality.
The possibility of being mistaken about goodness presupposes that there is a goodness about which one can be mistaken.
2 witnesses: Isaiah 5:20, CCC 1783
Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness.
Scripture can only reprove the calling of evil good if good and evil are not made by our calling.
Conscience must be informed and moral judgment enlightened.
The Church teaches that moral judgment can be formed well or badly, which assumes a truth it must conform to.
PonderRecall a time you said, “I thought this was good, but I was wrong.” What did that sentence assume?
Being and goodness are not unrelated realities
This becomes clearer when we examine what we mean by being. Being and goodness are convertible. Whatever exists, insofar as it exists, possesses some goodness. This does not mean that everything that exists is morally good. Evil is possible, but evil is not a positive thing in itself standing alongside goodness. Evil is a privation of a due good, a lack or disorder in something that ought to possess a certain perfection.
A thing is good insofar as it possesses the perfection proper to its nature. A thing is true insofar as it is what it is and can be known according to what it is. A thing is beautiful insofar as its form, order, proportion, and perfection manifest something of the excellence proper to what it is. Justice is goodness according to right order. Love seeks, delights in, and gives the good.
These are distinct concepts, and they should not be collapsed into one another. But as we go deeper, we begin to see that they do not point ultimately to unrelated realities. They converge in being. Truth is intelligibility in relation to being. Goodness is perfection in relation to being. Beauty is the manifestation of perfection and order in being. Justice is goodness expressed in proper order and relation. Love is the movement of the will toward the good.
They are different angles through which a finite intellect encounters reality, but their differences do not require different ultimate sources. Created goodness is not a private invention of the subject. Goodness belongs to being according to the perfection proper to each nature.
- The perfection of being as intelligible
- The perfection of being as desirable
- The perfection of being as harmonious
- The perfection of being as rightly ordered
- The perfection of being as self-giving
A thing is good insofar as it possesses the perfection proper to what it is. These are not five separate sources. They are different ways in which the one reality of being is encountered and described.
Whatever exists, insofar as it exists, possesses some goodness.
3 witnesses: Genesis 1:31, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.5 a.3, St Augustine, Confessions VII.12
And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good.
Scripture tells us that what God made is good simply in being what He made.
Every being, as being, is good.
St Thomas teaches the convertibility of being and goodness that this step draws from.
Therefore, whatsoever is, is good; and evil, whose origin I was seeking, is not a substance.
St Augustine confesses the same truth: evil is not a positive thing alongside goodness but a lack of it.
PonderHow do truth, goodness, beauty, justice and love differ, and where do they meet?
The creature receives what God is by Himself
The deeper question then becomes: what is the source of the being and goodness that we encounter everywhere? Everything we have, we receive.
We did not give ourselves existence. We did not create our own nature. We did not decide that we would be rational. We did not create the intellect by which we recognize truth. We did not create the will by which we desire and choose. We did not create the capacity by which we love. We did not establish the goods toward which our nature is ordered. We received all of these things.
There is therefore a fundamental distinction between God and everything else. The creature has being. God is Being. The creature participates in goodness. God is Goodness itself. The creature knows truth. God is Truth. The creature possesses beauty. God is Beauty. The creature loves according to a received participation in goodness. God is Love.
The creature does not participate in God because God is merely a very large being possessing very large quantities of these things. God is not one being among other beings. God is Being itself, the uncreated source from which all created being proceeds.
The distinction is therefore not simply one of degree. It is a distinction between the One who is by Himself and those who exist by participation. What we have is received. What God is, is not received. We are dependent. God is not.
- Tree, friendship, truth, justice, beauty, love
- They participate in goodness. They receive it.
- They are good, but their goodness is received, limited, and dependent.
- Goodness is not something God has. Goodness is what God is.
- The source of all goodness.
- Perfect. Infinite. Independent.
Created things receive goodness; God is Goodness itself. Key point: every good we find in creatures is a participation in the Good. God is not one good among others; He is the fullness of Goodness itself.
What we have is received; what God is, is not received.
4 witnesses: Exodus 3:14, CCC 213, Acts 17:28…
God said to Moses, “I AM WHO I AM.”
Scripture speaks of God as the One who simply is, not one who has being from another.
The revelation of the ineffable name “I AM WHO AM” contains then the truth that God alone IS.
The Church teaches that God alone is by Himself, while all else has being from Him.
In him we live and move and have our being.
St Paul reminds us that the creature’s very being is received and held in God.
He who does not love does not know God; for God is love.
These words are drawn from St John: God does not merely love, He is Love.
PonderName something you have that you did not give yourself. Is there anything you have that you did not receive?
We can judge reality, but we are not its measure
We can say that an action is good or evil. We can say that something is just or unjust. We can say that a proposition is true or false. We can say that something is beautiful or ugly. But the judgment does not create the standard by which the judgment is made.
We do not make murder evil by declaring it evil. We do not make charity good by approving of it. We do not create truth by discovering it. We do not create beauty by recognizing it. We discover, apprehend, and participate in realities that precede our judgments.
This is where subjectivism begins to encounter a serious problem. Suppose someone says that morality is nothing more than what he approves of. Then what distinguishes genuine justice from the mere feeling of approval? If I say, “This is just because I approve of it,” and another person says, “No, it is unjust because I disapprove of it,” then neither of us has yet given an account of justice itself. We have only described two psychological states.
We have explained how two people feel. We have not explained whether either one is correct.
But moral discourse ordinarily assumes that one can be correct and the other mistaken. We educate consciences. We correct moral judgments. We repent. We confess wrongdoing. We say, “I thought this was right, but I was wrong.” All of this presupposes an objective moral reality toward which our judgments can conform or fail to conform.
Subjective moral experience is real, but subjectivism cannot by itself explain the difference between a true moral judgment and a merely felt preference. The subjective act is real. But the subject is not therefore the source of the objective reality toward which the act is directed.
Subjectivism explains how people feel, but not who is right.
2 witnesses: Romans 2:15, CCC 1954
They show that what the law requires is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness.
St Paul reminds us that the moral law is found in us, not made by us.
The natural law expresses the original moral sense which enables man to discern by reason the good and the evil, the truth and the lie.
The Church teaches that reason discerns good and evil; it does not decree them.
PonderIf morality were only what each person approves of, what would it mean to repent?
Disordered goods, and why no created good is the Ultimate Good
A person who pursues something bad usually does not pursue it as bad. He pursues it because he sees some aspect of good in it. The thief wants money. The glutton wants pleasure. The proud person wants recognition. The vindictive person wants satisfaction or what he believes is restoration. The person who sins usually does not desire evil simply because it is evil. He desires some apparent good attached to the evil act, while ignoring, misunderstanding, or subordinating higher goods that the act violates.
A created good is genuinely good because it perfects something according to its nature. But a created good is not the Good itself. A good can become destructive when it is sought contrary to its proper nature, placed above a higher good, made the ultimate end, or asked to provide a perfection that belongs only to something higher.
Food is good. Sexuality is good. Family is good. Friendship is good. Knowledge is good. Health is good. Wealth can be good. Pleasure can be good. Recognition can sometimes be a good. But none of these is Goodness itself. Each is a finite good. Each perfects something. And therefore each has a proper place within the total order of the person’s life. The good itself has not ceased to be good. The disorder lies in the manner in which the creature relates to it: in measure, place, purpose, relation, or finality.
Family life is a great good. Marriage is a great good. Children are a great good. But if someone makes family life the highest and final good of his existence, he is asking a created good to provide a perfection it was never made to provide. He has taken something genuinely good and placed it in a position it cannot occupy. And therefore it cannot satisfy the deepest craving of the human person.
Food is not friendship, but food is still good. The fact that one good is not another does not make one of them fake goodness. Yet their very differences reveal their finitude. If food were the Good itself, there would be no reason for anything else to be good. If knowledge were the Good itself, friendship would be unnecessary. If pleasure were the Good itself, truth would be unnecessary. If family were the Good itself, justice would be unnecessary. Each created good leaves something outside itself. Each is incomplete. Each therefore points beyond itself.
A finite good can perfect us according to its nature. A finite good cannot supply the infinite fulfillment for which the creature ultimately longs. It can enrich our lives, but it cannot become God for us.
| Who | The good he sees | What he ignores or subordinates |
|---|---|---|
| The thief | Money | Justice toward his neighbour |
| The glutton | Pleasure | The measure proper to food and health |
| The proud person | Recognition | The truth about himself and about God |
| The vindictive person | Satisfaction, or what he believes is restoration | Justice and mercy |
The good being sought may be real, but the pursuit is disordered. A good becomes destructive when it is sought against its nature, placed above a higher good, made the ultimate end, or asked for a perfection that belongs only to something higher.
The problem is not necessarily the good itself; the problem is disorder.
3 witnesses: St Augustine, Confessions I.1, Exodus 20:3, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II q.2 a.8
You have made us for yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in you.
St Augustine confesses that no finite good can give the rest for which the heart was made.
You shall have no other gods before me.
Scripture forbids setting any created good in the place that belongs to God alone.
It is impossible for any created good to constitute man’s happiness.
St Thomas teaches the same truth: only the universal good, which is God, can satisfy the will.
PonderWhich good in your life are you most tempted to ask for more than it was made to give?
The web of created goods
The existence of apparent goods reveals several things about man.
- Man can be mistaken: he can perceive a real good but misunderstand its measure, place, purpose, or relation to other goods.
- Man needs guidance: his intellect is real and capable of knowing truth, but it is finite and can be disordered.
- Man needs unity: he cannot live rightly by pursuing isolated goods as though each existed independently of the rest.
- Man cannot perceive anything fully in isolation: the goodness of a thing is often intelligible through its nature, purpose, relations, consequences, and place within a larger order.
- Man must seek every good with the Ultimate Good in view: because every created good is finite, none can be the final perfection of the creature.
We cannot fully understand the good of food without considering the nature of the human body. We cannot fully understand sexuality without considering the human person, marriage, love, generation, responsibility, and the purpose of human sexuality. We cannot fully understand wealth without asking what wealth is for. We cannot fully understand pleasure without asking what pleasure perfects and whether it is ordered toward a genuine human good. We cannot understand justice without understanding the good of the persons and relationships involved.
The pursuit of goods therefore is not merely a matter of asking, “Is this good?” It is also a matter of asking how it is good, for whom it is good, what it is good for, what end it serves, what other goods it requires, what higher goods it supports, what goods it can damage when disordered, and how it relates to the Ultimate Good.
The goodness of everything in creation is interconnected. Created goods are not isolated pieces of goodness floating independently from one another. They point to each other because they are finite. Food points beyond itself to health, nourishment, life, action, and the activities for which the person is nourished. Friendship points beyond itself to love, communion, trust, sacrifice, and human flourishing. Knowledge can point toward wisdom. Beauty can point toward contemplation. Justice protects and orders relationships. Love can integrate many other goods.
The goods of creation form something like a vast web. The purpose of such a web is not to establish a perfectly rigid hierarchy in which every created good always occupies exactly the same rank under every circumstance. Created life is too complex for that. Circumstances matter. Responsibilities differ. Particular goods can become more urgent or more relevant according to the situation. The web shows something deeper: no finite good is sufficient in itself.
Food cannot be friendship. Friendship cannot be knowledge. Knowledge cannot be sexuality. Sexuality cannot be beauty. Beauty cannot be justice. Justice cannot be family. Family cannot be God. They are all genuine goods. But they are different goods precisely because each expresses or perfects a different aspect of created being.
The multiplicity of created goods reveals their finitude. Their interconnection reveals their participation in a common order. Their common goodness points beyond them to one ultimate source.
- Family
- Love
- Friends
- Speech
- Work
- Justice
- Water
- Food
- Health
- Sleep, rest
- Beauty
- Society, community
- Education, formation
- Culture, tradition
- Law, order
- Economy
- Country, nation
Created goods depend on other created goods to remain good; no good exists in isolation. To remain good they must be for the good of all men at all times, serving the whole person, body and soul. Ultimately they remain good when they are in accord with their design from God, who is Wisdom, Love, Goodness, Order and Truth, the source and designer of all goods: He establishes the order and sustains every good. When all goods are lived in this order, the person flourishes, society is just and peaceful, creation is honoured, and God is glorified. From God, through all goods in right order, for the good of all, back to God.
No finite good is sufficient in itself; each is understood through its place in a larger order.
3 witnesses: CCC 340, Wisdom 11:20, Colossians 1:17
No creature is self-sufficient. Creatures exist only in dependence on each other, to complete each other, in the service of each other.
The Church teaches that the interdependence of creatures shows that none is sufficient in itself.
Thou hast arranged all things by measure and number and weight.
Scripture speaks of an order given by God, within which each good has its measure and place.
He is before all things, and in him all things hold together.
St Paul reminds us that the unity of created things does not come from themselves.
PonderChoose one good, such as food, wealth or work. What do you need to know before you can say how it is good?
God is the source, not another node in the web
The entire web of created goods ultimately points upward to God. God is not simply another node in the web. God is not the largest good among many goods. God is not one finite good that happens to be infinitely larger. God is the source from whom every created good receives its being and goodness.
He is the living spring of life itself. The created goods are downstream. They receive from the source, and then, in different ways, communicate or mediate goodness to other creatures. Food gives nourishment. Friendship gives companionship. Knowledge gives intellectual perfection. Beauty gives delight and contemplation. Family gives relational and generative goods. Virtue orders the person toward the perfection proper to human nature. Yet none of these created streams is the spring.
The Sun and its light can serve as a useful analogy. The light that reaches us is not the Sun itself, yet it genuinely comes from the Sun and communicates something of the Sun’s reality to what receives it. Likewise, a creature does not become God by receiving being or goodness from God, but it genuinely participates in something that comes from Him.
Or consider iron placed in fire. The iron becomes hot. Its heat is real. But the iron did not originate the heat. It possesses what it has received. The creature is like that. We genuinely possess being. We genuinely possess goodness. We genuinely possess truth and beauty according to our measure. But we are not the source of what we possess.
The many goods of creation do not ultimately reveal a multiplicity of unrelated goodnesses. They reveal one goodness received and expressed in countless finite modes. The multiplicity is on our side. The limitation is on our side. The infinite source is one.
In creatures, truth, goodness, beauty, justice, and love are distinct ways of understanding and participating in perfection. In God, there is no division of perfections. God does not possess goodness as one thing, truth as another, beauty as another, and love as another, all held together like separate pieces. God is not composed of parts. His perfection is not assembled. His Being is not divided.
The true Good is not merely the greatest member of a class of goods. It is the fullness of Goodness, and therefore it is infinite, indivisible, and perfectly one. The finite goods are many because they are limited. The Good itself is one because it is unlimited. The many rays point to the one light. The streams point to the spring. The participated perfections point to the fullness of Perfection.
To participate in a perfection is to possess it genuinely without being its ultimate source.
4 witnesses: Psalm 36:9, James 1:17, CCC 41…
For with thee is the fountain of life; in thy light do we see light.
Scripture speaks of God as the fountain and the light, the same images of spring and sun used here.
Every good endowment and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights.
Scripture tells us that every created good comes down from one source.
The manifold perfections of creatures, their truth, their goodness, their beauty all reflect the infinite perfection of God.
The Church teaches that the many perfections of creatures reflect the one infinite perfection of God. Punctuation of the edition (dashes) rendered with commas here.
God is altogether simple.
St Thomas teaches that God is not composed of parts, which this step draws from in saying that His perfection is not assembled.
PonderHow do the images of the spring, the sun and the iron in the fire help you see both the reality of created goods and their dependence?
Finite and temporal: why the creature cannot be the judge of God
Why can we not understand justice perfectly? Why can we not comprehend truth perfectly? Why can we not exhaust goodness? Why can we not understand God perfectly? At a certain point, we are asking the same question in different forms: why can a limited thing not be unlimited?
Imagine a small, finite container. Someone asks, “Why can this container not hold an infinite amount of water?” There is no real mystery here. The inability of the container to contain infinity follows from its being limited. If you are asking why a limited thing cannot be unlimited, you have already answered much of the question by describing it as limited.
The same is true of us. We are finite. Therefore our intellect is finite. We can know truth genuinely, but we cannot know every truth exhaustively. We can understand justice truly, but we cannot contain the fullness of justice. We can recognize beauty, but we cannot exhaust beauty. We can know God truly, but we cannot comprehend God exhaustively. The absence of infinity is not an accidental defect in a finite creature. It is part of what it means to be finite.
We are not only limited. We are temporal. Why do we have to learn? Why do we reason from one truth to another? Why do we deliberate? Why do we forget? Why do we pass from potency to act? We do not possess our acts all at once. An eternal being does not have to wait for the future in order to know it. An eternal being does not acquire knowledge progressively. A temporal being does. So if someone asks, “Why can’t I possess all knowledge immediately and exercise it all at once?” the answer is contained in what we are. The question is effectively asking why the temporal cannot be eternal.
We can judge propositions about God. We can ask whether a statement about God is true. We can reason from creation to Creator. We can recognize His effects. But to judge God in the ultimate sense would require us to stand outside Him with an independent standard of Being, goodness, truth, or justice by which He Himself could be measured.
But where would such a standard exist? If the standard is created, it cannot stand above the uncreated source. If it is independent of God but possesses being, then it participates in the very reality it was supposedly established to judge from outside. If it does not possess being, then it cannot provide an ontological standard at all.
The position therefore collapses. The finite cannot become the measure of the Infinite. The temporal cannot become the standpoint from which Eternity is comprehensively judged. The participant cannot become the independent tribunal of the source in whom it participates.
- A cup of water: it has a limit.
- It can hold water. It can participate in water.
- A cup of water is good in its kind, but it is not all water.
- It has no limit, no boundary.
- The source of all water, not contained by any cup, beyond all measure.
- God is Goodness itself, not a part of Goodness: the fullness from which every good is received.
The finite can participate in the infinite, but it can never contain or exhaust it. The finite good depends on and points beyond itself. Key point: we can hold and use the good in creation, but we can never contain or replace the infinite Goodness that is God.
A finite intellect can know the infinite truly without comprehending it exhaustively, and the participant cannot become the tribunal of its source.
3 witnesses: Isaiah 55:9, Job 38:4, CCC 42
For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts.
Scripture tells us that God’s thoughts exceed ours, not as a contradiction of reason but as the infinite exceeds the finite.
Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Tell me, if you have understanding.
Scripture shows the creature that it has no standpoint outside creation from which to judge its Creator.
God transcends all creatures.
The Church teaches that we speak of God truly, yet always within the limits of creatures.
PonderWhat is the difference between judging a statement about God and setting oneself up as the judge of God?
Reception, order, and beauty: the whole movement back to God
Our natural knowledge of God is real but limited. We can reason from creation toward God. We can perceive His effects. We can recognize His wisdom, goodness, order, and beauty in creation. But if God is to give us knowledge of Himself beyond what our created intellect can naturally attain, that knowledge must be received. We do not conquer God intellectually. God gives Himself to be known. Even our highest knowledge of Him is received.
Revelation does not contradict reason. It fits the creature’s deepest condition. Being is received, goodness is received, truth is received, grace is received, revelation is received. The creature does not manufacture what it ultimately needs. The logic of creaturehood is the logic of reception.
This also returns us to the question of beauty. A thing is beautiful insofar as it manifests the perfection proper to its nature. The more a being is in accord with its nature, the more its beauty is manifested. And this applies to us. We do not become beautiful by inventing ourselves. We become beautiful by becoming what we were created to be.
If we are in disarray, we can lose the capacity to see clearly. It takes some degree of beauty to recognize beauty. The more ordered the subject becomes, the more capable the subject becomes of recognizing order in what is outside him. A person ordered toward truth becomes more capable of recognizing truth. A person ordered toward goodness becomes more capable of recognizing goodness. A person ordered toward beauty becomes more capable of recognizing beauty. Human disorder can impair the recognition of objective good and beauty without abolishing the reality of the good and beauty themselves.
Being ordered toward God is not an escape from reality. It is a movement toward reality. Because we were created for God, the more perfectly we are ordered toward God, the more perfectly we become ordered toward reality itself.
We began with ordinary judgments and discovered that they point beyond themselves to reality. From reality we moved to goodness, from goodness to the many finite goods, and from the many goods toward their one Source.
We are not the measure of reality. We are measured by it. We are not the source of goodness. We receive goodness. We are not the source of truth. We receive truth. We are not the source of beauty. We participate in beauty. We are not Being itself. We are beings who have received being.
Everything points beyond itself. The goods point to one another. The many point to the One. And ultimately, the One points to no other source.
He is the source.
He is Being itself.
He is the Good itself.
He is Truth.
He is Beauty.
He is Love.
And everything we have, everything we are, and every genuine good we have ever encountered is something we have received from Him.
- Judgment: see, think, judge
- Reality: truth, goodness, beauty, justice
- Finite goods: many goods, received
- Right order: whole person, common good
- God: source, fullness
The many point to the One. The finite points to the Infinite. The received points to the Giver. Every genuine good is received, ordered, and fulfilled in its relation to God.
The more rightly ordered we become toward God, the more clearly we see what is.
4 witnesses: Matthew 5:8, CCC 50, CCC 2500…
Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God.
Our Lord teaches that a rightly ordered heart sees more truly.
There exists another order of knowledge, which man cannot possibly arrive at by his own powers: the order of divine Revelation.
The Church teaches that knowledge of God beyond natural reason is received as gift.
Even before revealing himself to man in words of truth, God reveals himself to him through the universal language of creation.
The Church teaches that the order and beauty of creation already speak of God.
Late have I loved you, O Beauty ever ancient, ever new, late have I loved you!
St Augustine confesses the movement this lecture traces: from beautiful things to Beauty itself.
PonderWhere in your life has disorder made it harder to see goodness or beauty, and where has growing order made it easier?
Good and God at a glance
| Principle | What it means | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Judgment and reality | Our judgments are acts in us that respond to what is really there | Without a reality beyond our judgments, nothing that follows can begin |
| Error | We can be wrong about goodness and beauty | Error presupposes a standard beyond the judgment |
| Being and goodness | Whatever exists is good insofar as it exists; evil is a privation | Truth, goodness, beauty, justice and love converge in being |
| Reception | The creature has being; God is Being | We are dependent; God is the uncreated source |
| Measure | We judge by a standard we do not make | Subjectivism cannot tell a true judgment from a felt preference |
| Disorder | Sin seeks a real good in the wrong measure, place or finality | No finite good can be asked to be God |
| The web | Created goods depend on one another and on a larger order | No finite good is sufficient in itself |
| The source | God is not a node in the web but the spring of every good | In Him every perfection is perfectly one |
| Limits | We are finite and temporal | We know God truly but cannot comprehend or judge Him |
| Order and beauty | We become beautiful by becoming what we were made to be | The more ordered we are toward God, the more clearly we see |
Study it
For a group or on your own. Tick each question as you answer it; your ticks stay on this device.
- We do not create goodness, truth or beauty; we encounter them, participate in them, and are ordered by them.
- The possibility of error presupposes a distinction between appearance and reality.
- Being and goodness are convertible; evil is a privation of a due good.
- Everything created is received: the creature has being, God is Being itself.
- Every finite good has a proper nature, purpose and place; disorder comes when it is asked to be the Ultimate Good.
- Created goods form an interconnected web of finite participations that point to one source, in whom every perfection is one.
- Being finite and temporal, we can know God truly but neither exhaust Him nor stand outside Being to judge Him.
- The logic of creaturehood is the logic of reception, and the more ordered we become toward God, the more clearly we see what is.
“For with thee is the fountain of life; in thy light do we see light.”Psalm 36:9
Take, Lord, and receive all my liberty, my memory, my understanding, and my entire will, all that I have and possess. Thou hast given all to me. To Thee, O Lord, I return it. All is Thine; dispose of it wholly according to Thy will. Give me Thy love and Thy grace, for this is sufficient for me.
St Ignatius of Loyola, Suscipe
← LecturesLecture 04