- Evil is not a thing standing beside God but the privation of a good that ought to be present in something good.
- God does not watch history unfold moment by moment: He sees the beginning, the middle and the end in one eternal act.
- Justice is giving another what is due; God, who gives everything, can owe man nothing except what He owes to His own promise.
- The meaning of a life cannot be judged while ignoring its end: the Cross was not understood on Good Friday but on Easter Sunday.
- The very reason by which man judges God is a gift received from God and sustained by Him; man has no neutral standpoint outside his Creator.
- The limits of creatures are not evils, and an unlimited creature is a contradiction; moral evil comes from the free failure of finite wills.
- Our ignorance of God's reasons is not proof that He has none; the Christian answer is faith and hope in the God who entered our suffering.
We have been looking into the nature of the Church for weeks, but because of a question posed by one of our members, how to defend against a quasi-atheistic view of God's justice, we have decided to turn our attention in this direction. At the request of another member, I have put my arguments in writing so that everyone can read them beforehand, follow the reasoning, and come ready to contribute more to the discussion that follows.
The crux of the objection raised by a third party to one of our members is this:
How can we believe God to be just with all the seemingly needless suffering of human beings around the world? Would that not make God unjust for allowing it?
Before we begin to answer this objection, there are a few things that need addressing.
The question beneath the question
Firstly, the source of this objection is not one single idea but a collection of assumptions and philosophical commitments. It is a conclusion that follows from a particular way of looking at reality. Because of this, our response will also be slow, careful, and directed toward those underlying assumptions. No single answer will suffice as a knock-down response to the problem of evil. What follows is an exploration of the assumptions behind the objection itself to see whether the conclusion actually follows.
Secondly, the person asking this question should be engaged with patience if they are sincerely trying to understand the full scope of the problem and are willing to approach it systematically rather than only emotionally. The problem of suffering touches every human being, so it deserves to be taken seriously. At the same time, emotional approaches do not always allow for genuine intellectual engagement, nor do they always lead us to the truth. So if a charge is brought against God, we first want to know whether the charge is fair and whether the accuser is actually speaking about God, or something else entirely.
Thirdly, it is important to know what our words and concepts actually mean. If we speak of "justice" and "injustice," we first want to know what those words mean and whether they properly apply to God in the way the objection assumes. Since our goal is to arrive at the truth rather than simply win an argument, taking the time to define our terms is a critical step that is often overlooked.
Finally, we are not attempting to explain every instance of suffering or answer every emotional question a person may have. We want to ask a much more specific question: does the conclusion, "Therefore God is unjust," actually follow from the evidence being presented? If the conclusion does not logically follow, then however emotionally compelling the objection may be, it has not yet proved its case.
Steelmanning the objection. Let us first strengthen the objection properly so that we are not avoiding the question by answering a weaker version of it. If God is all-good, all-powerful, and all-loving, why would He permit seemingly needless evils in the world that appear to serve no higher purpose? Why, for instance, would a child die of cancer at all, or suffer under circumstances that seem completely pointless? This is a genuinely powerful question, and it is this stronger form that we hope to answer.
In brief, a direct answer.
- We do not know, and we cannot fully know, why God permits any specific instance of suffering. But this lack of access speaks more about our own limitedness than about any absence of reason; it says nothing at all about the injustice of God.
- We can know that evils can serve higher purposes. What we cannot always know is which specific purpose a specific evil serves. That gap in our knowledge does not mean the suffering is pointless; it only means we lack access to the information we would need to see the purpose ourselves.
- We also know that God is necessarily good and just, both in accord with His own nature and with a logical account of existence itself.
What follows is the fuller argument behind that answer.
- Suffering exists
- We see no reason for it
- So there is no reason
- So God is unjust
The step from "we see no reason" to "there is no reason" is the one the objection never proves.
We are asking one thing only: does "Therefore God is unjust" actually follow from the evidence?
2 witnesses: Catechism of the Catholic Church 309, Isaiah 55:8–9
To this question, as pressing as it is unavoidable and as painful as it is mysterious, no quick answer will suffice.
The Church teaches, as the lecture says, that no single answer settles the question of evil, and that only the Christian faith as a whole answers it.
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, says the LORD. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts.
Scripture tells us that God's purposes exceed our sight, which is why our not seeing a reason does not show that none exists.
PonderWhy is it important to answer the strongest form of an objection rather than a weaker one?
What evil is
Before we continue, it is helpful to ask a number of questions first. What is evil? Who is God? What is justice? Can suffering be meaningful? If so, on what is that meaning based? How do we determine it? Can an apparent evil ultimately serve a greater good? How does God know, and how does that differ from the way we know? Since these are some of the assumptions made by the objector, they need to be answered carefully before we can know whether the conclusion actually follows.
Evil is a privation, the absence of a good that ought to be there, not a substance. Evil is not something that exists alongside the rest of creation or alongside God, but the absence of a good or perfection proper to a being. So blindness is not something we can point to and say, "This is blindness existing on its own." Blindness always occurs in an otherwise good eye. Blindness is simply the absence of sight. In the same way, darkness is not a positive thing but merely the absence of light.
This is very important because whenever someone says that something is evil, we first need to understand what evil actually is. St Augustine makes this argument in the Enchiridion, and many later theologians, including St Thomas Aquinas, develop it further. What we call evil is not a "thing" with its own existence, but the absence or corruption of a good that ought to be present in something that is, in itself, good. Disease is not something added to the body. It is health lacking. Sin is not a positive power. It is the will falling short of the good for which it was made.
Evil therefore has no independent existence to be weighed against God's goodness as though the two stood side by side. It exists only as a wound or defect in something that remains fundamentally good.
- An eye
- A body
- Light
- A will made for the good
- Blindness: sight lacking
- Disease: health lacking
- Darkness: light lacking
- Sin: the will falling short
Every evil on the right exists only as a lack in something on the left.
Evil is not a thing beside God but the absence of a good that ought to be present in something good.
3 witnesses: St Augustine, Enchiridion 11, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.49 a.1, Genesis 1:31
For what is that which we call evil but the absence of good? In the bodies of animals, disease and wounds mean nothing but the absence of health.
St Augustine speaks of disease as the absence of health, the same example the lecture uses.
For evil is the absence of the good, which is natural and due to a thing.
St Thomas teaches that evil is not any lack at all, but the lack of a good due to a thing, as sight is due to an eye.
And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good.
Scripture tells us that all God made is good, so evil can only be a wound in what is good, never a second thing beside it.
PonderIf blindness is not "a thing," what exactly is wrong with a blind eye?
Moral, physical and metaphysical evil
It is worth developing this distinction a little further.
Moral evil is the evil that arises from the free choices of rational creatures. In other words, sin. It is the misuse of the freedom God has given us.
Physical evil is the privation of some bodily or natural good due to a creature. Blindness, disease, injury, and death are all examples of physical evils. A physical evil does not necessarily arise because someone chose to do wrong. A child may be born blind because of a genetic condition, or someone may suffer through natural causes where no one directly chose to harm them. This is why it is important to distinguish physical evil from moral evil, because moral evil always involves the movement of a rational will.
We will leave metaphysical evil until later because it is not really an "evil" in the proper sense. Moral and physical evils are genuine privations of goods due to a creature. Metaphysical "evil" simply refers to the limitations that belong to creatures because they are creatures, with the word "evil" being used only in an analogous or loose sense.
- Sin
- Misuse of freedom
- Always involves a will
- Blindness, disease
- Injury, death
- Need not involve a will
- Limits of creatures
- Not truly an evil
- Used only loosely
Moral evil is sin, physical evil is the loss of a bodily or natural good, and "metaphysical evil" is only the limit of being a creature.
2 witnesses: Catechism of the Catholic Church 311, Wisdom 1:13–14
Angels and men, as intelligent and free creatures, have to journey toward their ultimate destinies by their free choice and preferential love. They can therefore go astray. Indeed, they have sinned. Thus has moral evil, incommensurably more harmful than physical evil, entered the world.
The Church teaches the same distinction between moral and physical evil, and that moral evil comes from free choice.
because God did not make death, and he does not delight in the death of the living. For he created all things that they might exist.
Scripture tells us that God made things to exist; death and corruption are not His handiwork in the way creatures are.
PonderWhy does it matter whether a given suffering comes from a will or from natural causes?
God's mode of knowing
When a child is sick and needs medical care, the parent can "see," in some sense, the purpose of the injection given to the child, while the child cannot. The child cries because all he experiences is the pain, and sometimes even feels that his parents are being unjust for restraining him and forcing him to receive the injection. The parent is able to "see" the end, and this is often compared to how God sees the end from the beginning. Even this, however, falls far short of the way God knows.
We see in succession. One moment passes and another comes. We remember the past imperfectly, experience only the present, and know very little about the future.
God is eternal. He is not merely seeing the end from the beginning. He sees the beginning, the middle, and the end together in one eternal act of knowing. There is no future for God to look ahead to, nor is there a past for Him to remember. Everything is immediately present to Him. So, in one sense, if you are twenty-three years old today, you are only twenty-three to yourself right now. But God sees your conception, your childhood, your adulthood, your old age, your death, and your eternal destiny in one simple and undivided act. Only God sees you completely. You experience yourself gradually, one moment at a time.
St Augustine anticipates this in Book XI of the Confessions, where he reflects on the nature of time itself and concludes that time is a creature, not something God is contained within. St Thomas Aquinas later develops this more systematically, teaching that God's knowledge is not caused by things happening. Rather, things happen because they are eternally known and willed by God. The Catechism likewise teaches that God's providence is the way the whole of creation is ordered and directed toward its proper end. Boethius gives the classical definition of eternity itself in the Consolation of Philosophy, describing it not as endless duration through time but as the whole, simultaneous, and complete possession of unending life in a single act.
This is important because the charge against God often imagines Him as though He were a very powerful human ruler standing aside while history unfolds and choosing, moment by moment, not to intervene while everything falls apart. But God is not a temporal observer. He is not waiting too long before acting because He is not bound by time as we are.
Bear in mind that this response does not mean the evils suffered in the meantime are not real. Nor does it remove the pain of suffering. It is responding to the charge of injustice specifically. If we are going to accuse God of injustice, then the whole order of His providence must be taken into account, not merely one moment within it. The objector therefore has to show not simply that suffering exists, but that no sufficient reason could possibly exist within the whole of God's providence for permitting it. That is a much stronger claim than merely pointing to suffering itself.
- In succession
- Past remembered imperfectly
- Only the present
- Little of the future
- In one eternal act
- Nothing past to remember
- All things present
- Nothing future to foresee
God is not a ruler watching from the sidelines, waiting too long to act.
God does not watch history from within time: He knows the beginning, the middle and the end in one eternal act.
4 witnesses: Boethius, The Consolation of Philosophy V, prose 6, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.14 a.13, 2 Peter 3:8…
Eternity, then, is the whole, simultaneous and complete possession of unending life (interminabilis vitae tota simul et perfecta possessio).
The lecture draws its definition of eternity from these words of Boethius.
His glance is carried from eternity over all things as they are in their presentiality.
St Thomas teaches that all things are present to God's eternity, which is the ground of the lecture's picture of God seeing a whole life at once.
But do not ignore this one fact, beloved, that with the Lord one day is as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.
Scripture answers the charge that God waits too long by reminding us that He is not measured by our time.
We call "divine providence" the dispositions by which God guides his creation toward this perfection.
The Church teaches that providence concerns the whole of creation moving to its end, not isolated moments.
PonderHow does the picture of God as a "powerful ruler standing aside" distort the objection?
Justice and injustice
To accuse someone of injustice is to say that he has failed to give another what is due to them. But this kind of accusation does not really work between man and God because God could never owe man anything. Man is a creature of complete dependence who continually receives everything he is from God. Justice requires a relation in which something is owed, but in the strict sense this cannot apply to the relationship between man and God.
Since man receives his very being and every good that comes with it from God, he can never place God in His debt. Any good that could ever become due to man already rests upon an earlier gift that God was never obliged to give in the first place. Man's very nature, his purpose, and even the promises God freely makes are all gifts given before any question of what is due can even arise. The relationship between God and man means that man owes everything to God, while God, by metaphysical necessity, owes nothing to man.
But if we are speaking of a debt that arises from God's own free and merciful promise, such as His promise that glory will follow grace, then we can speak of God being bound in a certain sense. He is bound because, having freely promised it, He owes it to Himself, according to His own free ordination, to keep His word. Not because He is bound by some standard of justice outside His own nature. God is just by His very essence, and no law exists to govern Him from without.
If you think, "Isn't this circular reasoning? Isn't the reason for God's justice simply God Himself?" then yes, that is exactly the point. We are not speaking of some really great man who happens to be more powerful than everyone else. We are speaking of God, who is Being itself and the source of all that is good. Since being and goodness are inseparable, the One who is Being itself is also Goodness itself.
So when someone accuses God of injustice, they are saying that the One who is Goodness itself somehow lacks goodness, or that the source of all justice is Himself unjust. But injustice is not a perfection. It is a lack of what ought to be there. Since God is infinitely perfect and lacks nothing, injustice cannot exist in Him.
The charge that "God is unjust" is therefore not simply an accusation against one being among many. It is an accusation against the very source of justice itself. Before such a charge can succeed, it must first show that this is even metaphysically possible. Only then could it hope to show that it is actually true.
Justice is giving what is due, and the Creator who gives everything can owe man nothing, except what He owes to His own promise.
4 witnesses: Romans 11:35–36, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.21 a.1 ad 3, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II q.114 a.1 ad 3…
Or who has given a gift to him that he might be repaid? For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory for ever. Amen.
St Paul reminds us that no one can put God in his debt, since all things come from Him.
And although God in this way pays each thing its due, yet He Himself is not the debtor, since He is not directed to other things, but rather other things to Him.
St Thomas teaches the same point in other words: God gives each thing its due, yet is never man's debtor.
God is not made our debtor simply, but His own, inasmuch as it is right that His will should be carried out.
The lecture's words, that God "owes it to Himself" to keep His promise, echo this teaching of St Thomas.
The Rock, his work is perfect; for all his ways are justice. A God of faithfulness and without iniquity, just and right is he.
Scripture confesses that injustice has no place in God.
PonderIf God owes man nothing, in what sense can we still call God just?
The eschatological horizon
Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that we could speak of injustice in this creature-Creator relationship. How might we come to the conclusion of injustice if we cannot see the full story? A "pessimistic" reading of human suffering is only possible if the accounting stops at death. The Catholic claim is that any "calculation" of divine justice which arbitrarily cuts off the consideration at the grave is not measuring truthfully because it refuses to consider man's final end, which is precisely the point from which the whole of life receives its meaning.
So when an atheist says, "Without involving the afterlife, tell me how your God could possibly be just," granting for the moment the misuse of the word justice, he has already cut off the very end that gives life its meaning. No one can define the objective value or meaning of life outside of God. (That claim is itself a further argument, the moral argument for God's existence, which we are not attempting to establish here.) Even granting only that a life's meaning depends in some way on the end for which it was made, no honest accounting of whether that life was treated justly can stop at the grave, since doing so simply ignores the end that was supposed to settle the question.
Everything is understood according to its end. The meaning of a race is not known before the finish line, nor the meaning of a story before its conclusion. In the same way, the meaning of a human life cannot be judged while ignoring the end for which it was created. God governs the whole order of creation toward its proper end, whereas we judge from within history, seeing only small and successive moments.
God has revealed in Christ that suffering itself can acquire a new meaning when viewed from its end. Without the Resurrection of Jesus Christ and the salvation that proceeds from it, His death would have been an execution and nothing more. But from the greatest evil ever committed, the murder of the only Son of God, came the greatest good, the salvation of the human race. The meaning of the Cross was not fully visible on Good Friday. It was revealed on Easter Sunday.
In the same way, that good can come from what appears to be evil is often only knowable from the end and not from the middle of suffering itself. At most, we can say that we do not know why this or that person has suffered or is suffering. But we cannot logically conclude from that ignorance that their suffering is meaningless, has no value, is needless, or constitutes such a grave evil that God must therefore be guilty of injustice.
We judge history from within history. God governs history as its Author. This limitation does not arise from some defect in God, but from the very nature of finite creatures attempting to judge the providence of the infinite Creator.
- The greatest evil
- Good Friday: the Cross
- Easter Sunday
- Salvation of the human race
On Good Friday the Cross looked like an execution and nothing more.
No honest accounting of a life can stop at the grave: the meaning of the Cross was revealed on Easter Sunday.
4 witnesses: Catechism of the Catholic Church 312, Romans 8:18, St Augustine, Enchiridion 11…
From the greatest moral evil ever committed, the rejection and murder of God's only Son, caused by the sins of all men, God, by his grace that "abounded all the more", brought the greatest of goods: the glorification of Christ and our redemption.
The lecture's words on the greatest evil and the greatest good are drawn from this teaching of the Church.
I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worth comparing with the glory that is to be revealed to us.
St Paul reminds us that present suffering must be weighed against the glory to come, not judged apart from it.
For the Almighty God, who, as even the heathen acknowledge, has supreme power over all things, being Himself supremely good, would never permit the existence of anything evil among His works, if He were not so omnipotent and good that He can bring good even out of evil.
St Augustine teaches that God permits evil only because He is able to bring good even out of it.
We firmly believe that God is master of the world and of its history. But the ways of his providence are often unknown to us. Only at the end, when our partial knowledge ceases, when we see God "face to face", will we fully know the ways by which, even through the dramas of evil and sin, God has guided his creation to that definitive sabbath rest for which he created heaven and earth.
The Church teaches, as the lecture does, that the ways of providence are known fully only from the end.
PonderWhat changes in the question of suffering when we refuse to stop the accounting at death?
Reason as a gift
Next we examine the faculty by which the objector arrives at the conclusion that "God is unjust." We have already seen that God is Himself the standard and source of all created justice and goodness. So by what faculty does man arrive at such a judgment?
The faculty by which man knows truth is called the intellect, or reason. It is like the eye of the soul by which a person "sees" immaterial realities. If I said, "There are two sheep in the barn," you could walk into the barn and use your physical eyes to verify whether my statement corresponds to reality. In a similar way, the intellect is the spiritual faculty by which we grasp truths that cannot be seen with our bodily eyes. It does not create truth but discovers it by conforming itself to reality. This conformity of the intellect to reality is what we call truth.
Now this intellect is itself a created power. It is not self-existent or self-sustaining. It is a gift received from God and continuously sustained by Him from moment to moment. The intellect is therefore not something man possesses independently of God, but something he possesses only by participation in the Being of God.
So what is the objector really claiming? He is claiming that, with an intellect given to him by God, sustained by God at this very moment, and enlightened by the light of reason, which itself has its source in God, he is able to judge that this same God is unjust. This does not, by itself, prove that God is just. A person can misuse his intellect and arrive at false conclusions. But it does show that man never occupies a position of independence from which he can stand over and against God as though he were a neutral judge.
This is not to say that man cannot reason about God or ask difficult questions. On the contrary, God created man with an intellect precisely so that he might seek truth. But it does mean that man cannot claim to judge God from some independent standpoint, because no such standpoint exists. The creature never stands outside the Creator.
The very reason by which man judges God is received from God and sustained by Him, so man has no neutral standpoint outside his Creator.
4 witnesses: Romans 9:20, Psalm 36:9, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.84 a.5…
But who are you, a man, to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, "Why have you made me thus?"
St Paul reminds us that the creature does not stand over its Maker as judge.
For with thee is the fountain of life; in thy light do we see light.
Scripture tells us that our seeing depends on God's light, as the lecture says of the light of reason.
For the intellectual light which is in us, is nothing else than a participated likeness of the uncreated light.
St Thomas teaches that our light of reason is a participation in God's own light.
Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Tell me, if you have understanding.
When Job questions God's justice, the Lord answers by recalling the difference between Creator and creature.
PonderDoes this argument forbid hard questions about God? Why or why not?
Limited creatures, not evil ones
What is sometimes called metaphysical evil is not really an evil at all. It is simply another way of describing the limitations that belong to creatures because they are creatures. A rock cannot grow. A plant can grow but cannot move from place to place or experience sensation. An animal can grow, move, and sense the world around it, but it cannot reason. A human person possesses a rational soul but is still not a purely spiritual being like an angel. Angels are spiritual beings, yet they too are finite and are not God. None of these limitations are defects. They are simply the boundaries that belong to each creature according to the kind of thing it is.
This raises an important question. If God is all-powerful, why create a world in which such limitations exist at all? Why not simply create unlimited creatures?
The answer is that an unlimited creature is not something that can exist. It is a contradiction in terms. To be a creature means to receive existence from another. To be unlimited means to exist without limit and to possess existence of oneself. But only God exists in this way. God is not one being among many. He is Being itself. So asking why God did not create an unlimited creature is like asking why He did not create a square circle.
This is why God's omnipotence is not called into question. Omnipotence does not mean the ability to do what is logically contradictory. It means the ability to do all things that are possible. Contradictions are not "things" waiting to be created. If God creates, He necessarily creates finite beings.
This also helps us understand why creation contains many different kinds of creatures. No single creature can fully reflect the infinite goodness of God. Instead, God created a world filled with many different kinds of beings, each possessing its own limited perfection. Together they display the richness of God's goodness far more fully than any one creature ever could. St Thomas makes this same point in the Summa Theologiae, teaching that God multiplied and diversified creatures precisely so that what was wanting to one, in representing the divine goodness, might be supplied by another.
The discussion of moral evil is different. The mere fact that a creature is finite does not make it evil, nor does it force a rational creature to sin. Because a rational creature possesses a finite and created freedom, it is capable of directing that freedom either toward God or away from Him. It does not follow that sin is inevitable. The holy angels and the saints in heaven remain finite creatures, yet they do not sin. Moral evil therefore does not arise because God created finite beings, but because some finite rational creatures freely fail to order themselves toward the good for which they were made.
- AngelPure spirit, yet finite
- Human personRational soul, yet embodied
- AnimalGrows, moves, senses; cannot reason
- PlantGrows; cannot move or sense
- RockExists; cannot grow
None of these limits is a defect: each is the boundary of a kind of thing. Only God is unlimited.
An unlimited creature is a contradiction, so the limits of creatures are not evils but part of the order of creation.
3 witnesses: St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.47 a.1, St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I q.25 a.3, Catechism of the Catholic Church 310
He produced many and diverse creatures, that what was wanting to one in the representation of the divine goodness might be supplied by another.
The lecture draws its account of the variety of creatures from this article of St Thomas.
Whatever implies contradiction does not come within the scope of divine omnipotence, because it cannot have the aspect of possibility.
St Thomas teaches, as the lecture says, that omnipotence concerns all that is possible, and a contradiction is not a possible thing.
But why did God not create a world so perfect that no evil could exist in it? With infinite power God could always create something better. But with infinite wisdom and goodness God freely willed to create a world "in a state of journeying" towards its ultimate perfection.
The Church teaches that God freely willed a world of creatures still on the way to their perfection.
PonderWhy is "Why did God not create unlimited creatures?" like asking for a square circle?
Putting God back in His place
The purpose of this discussion has never been to give one simple answer that explains every instance of suffering or solves the problem of evil once and for all. Such a task is beyond us. Rather, we have tried to examine some of the assumptions that usually lie behind the accusation, "Therefore God is unjust," and ask whether that conclusion actually follows.
Many objections are not really directed at God as He truly is, but at a caricature of Him. They often imagine God as though He were simply a much greater version of a human ruler, standing within time, watching events unfold, and choosing whether or not to intervene. But that is not the God revealed by reason or by the Catholic faith. If we are going to accuse God of injustice, we must first be sure that we are speaking about God and not something else.
Suffering is real. Grief is real. Loss is real. None of the arguments we have made are intended to deny that. Rather, we have tried to ask whether those realities, painful as they are, logically prove that God is unjust. We have argued that they do not.
Most importantly, the answer to evil is not ultimately found in a philosophical argument, but in the whole of God's revelation in Jesus Christ. The history of salvation is the story of creation, freedom, sin, suffering, redemption, and glory. We experience these realities one moment at a time. God sees them as one whole.
We are limited in two ways. First, because we are finite, we cannot comprehend the mind of God or His designs exhaustively. A limited container cannot hold what is without limit. Secondly, because we live and know within time, even our limited knowledge comes to us gradually, in fragmented moments. Our inability to see the whole is not proof that there is no whole to see, nor is our ignorance of God's reasons proof that He has none.
In the end, the Christian response to suffering is not blind cynicism, because that would mean claiming to draw conclusions that man, by his very nature as a finite creature, is incapable of drawing. Nor is it blind optimism, because that would mean denying the reality of pain and of evil in general. The Christian response is one of faith and hope in the God who alone is infinite enough to see all things and therefore alone is capable of judging perfectly what is just and unjust. It is also faith and hope in the God who entered into our suffering in Jesus Christ, conquered sin and death through His Cross and Resurrection, and has promised to bring all things to their proper end in Him.
We rightly sense that evil ought to be judged, that the world needs a Savior, and perhaps even that evil demands a sacrificial victim. None of these instincts are wrong. But somewhere along the way we have mistaken these instincts for a qualification to judge the whole of reality. Once we place ourselves in the seat of the final judge, we necessarily remove God from it and make Him the object of our judgment. The creature now judges the Creator, the finite judges the Infinite, and the one who sees only in fragments judges the One who sees all things in one eternal act. When the creature attempts to take the place of the Creator, it causes the ruin of the creature.
The correction therefore begins where the error began. It begins by putting God back in His proper place and ourselves back in ours.
Our inability to see the whole is not proof that there is no whole to see, nor is our ignorance of God's reasons proof that He has none.
3 witnesses: 1 Corinthians 13:12, Catechism of the Catholic Church 324, Revelation 21:4
For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall understand fully, even as I have been fully understood.
St Paul reminds us that our knowledge now is partial, and full understanding belongs to the end.
The fact that God permits physical and even moral evil is a mystery that God illuminates by his Son Jesus Christ who died and rose to vanquish evil.
The Church teaches, as the lecture concludes, that the final answer to evil is found in Christ crucified and risen.
he will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning nor crying nor pain any more, for the former things have passed away.
Scripture tells us of the end toward which God brings all things, the end from which suffering is finally judged.
PonderWhere in your own life have you placed yourself in the seat of the final judge?
The problem of evil at a glance
| Objection | The answer | Witness |
|---|---|---|
| Evil is a real force set against God. | Evil is the privation of a due good in something good, not a thing beside God. | St Augustine, Enchiridion 11; ST I q.49 a.1 |
| God watches suffering and waits too long. | God is eternal and knows the whole of history in one act; He is not a temporal observer. | Boethius, Consolation V; ST I q.14 a.13 |
| God owes us a world without suffering. | God owes man nothing; He owes it to Himself to keep what He freely promises. | Romans 11:35; ST I q.21 a.1 |
| This suffering is plainly pointless. | Meaning is read from the end; the Cross was understood on Easter Sunday. | CCC 312, 314; Romans 8:18 |
| My reason judges that God is unjust. | Reason is a gift sustained by God; there is no neutral standpoint outside Him. | Romans 9:20; Psalm 36:9 |
| An all-powerful God would make unlimited creatures. | An unlimited creature is a contradiction; limits are not evils. | ST I q.47 a.1; ST I q.25 a.3 |
| Since I see no reason, there is none. | Ignorance of God's reasons is not proof that He has none. | 1 Corinthians 13:12; CCC 324 |
Study it
For a group or on your own. Tick each question as you answer it; your ticks stay on this device.
- The objection is not one idea but a set of assumptions; the question is whether "Therefore God is unjust" follows.
- Evil is the privation of a good that ought to be present, not a thing beside God.
- Moral evil is sin; physical evil is the loss of a bodily or natural good; "metaphysical evil" is only the limit of a creature.
- God knows all of history in one eternal act; He is not a ruler waiting within time.
- God cannot be man's debtor; He is just by His essence and faithful to His own promises.
- A life cannot be judged while ignoring its end: Good Friday is understood from Easter Sunday.
- Reason itself is God's gift, so man has no standpoint outside God from which to judge Him.
- The answer is faith and hope in the God who entered our suffering in Christ, with God back in His place and ourselves in ours.
“Our inability to see the whole is not proof that there is no whole to see, nor is our ignorance of God's reasons proof that He has none.”Kenneth C. Alimba
O my God, relying on Thy infinite goodness and promises, I hope to obtain pardon of my sins, the help of Thy grace, and life everlasting, through the merits of Jesus Christ, my Lord and Redeemer. Amen.
Act of Hope, traditional
← LecturesLecture 03 · Know Your Faith Circle